Ste. Genevieve Library as a Criticism of Classicism

• Journal title : Architectural research
• Volume 15, Issue 1,  2013, pp.17-23
• Publisher : Architectural Institute of Korea
• DOI : 10.5659/AIKAR.2013.15.1.17
Title & Authors
Ste. Genevieve Library as a Criticism of Classicism
Kang, Tae-Woong;

Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to reconsider and revaluate Ste. Genevieve Library designed by Henri Labrouste as a criticism of Classicism. Considered as the epitome of the early structural Rationalism the modern historian tried to focus only on the iron structure of the library. Arguably, the structural concern was one of the ideas that the architect wanted to manifest in the library. As a rebel against a view of the Acad$\small{\acute{e}}$mie des Beaux-Art the notions of H. Labrouste were radical. He criticized an autistic Classicism with an echoing Claude Perrault's doubt about the myth of classical beauty. These radical ideas firstly showed in his report of the Grand Prix de Rome and must have been developed through several discussions for a novel: Notre-Dame de Paris by V. Hugo. 'Ceci tuera cela', one of the chapter of the novel, was generally known as the death of architecture due to the invention of the printing press around Renaissance period. We, however, consider that even though the historical background of the novel is the Gothic period the ideas, which was discussed with Labrouste, related to the death of architecture was not the architecture itself but classical architecture recomposed during Renaissance period. As the first design work the library must be reflected his ideas, which were developed, and manifested his criticism of the Classicism indirectly.
Keywords
Ste. Genevieve Library;Henri Labrouste;Claude Perralut;Victor Marie Hugo;Classicism;
Language
English
Cited by
References
1.
Van Zanten, D. (1987) Designing Pries, London: The MIT Press

2.
Giedion, S. (1997) Space, Time and Architecture, 4th ed., Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press

3.
Pevsner, N. (1968) The Sources of Modern Architecture and Design, London: Thames and Hudson

4.
Middelton, R. and Watkin, D. (1980) Neoclassical and 19Th Century Architecture,New York: Harry N. Abrams, Inc., Publisher

5.
Middleton, R. (ed.) The Beaux-arts and nineteenth-century French architecture. 1st MIT Press ed., Cambridge MA. : MIT Press

6.
Herrmann, W. (1973) The theory of Claude Perrault. London: A. Zwemmer

7.
Rykwert, J. (1980) The first moderns : the architects of the eighteenth century, Cambridge MA: MIT Press

8.
Bergdoll, B. (2000) European architecture 1750-1890, New York: Oxford University Press

9.
Kruft, H. (1994) A History of Architectural Theory from Vitruvius to The present, (Eng. ed.), New York: Princeton Architectural Press

10.
Henry Frances Mallgrave (2009) Modern Architectural Theory: A historical survey,1673-1968, New York: Cambridge university Press

11.
Hugo, V.(2011) The Hunchback of Notre Dame, London, The Harper Press

12.
Anthony Vidler, 1993, representations 42

13.
Curl, J. S. (1999) Dictionalry of Architecture, Oxford: Oxford Press University

14.
Jestaz, B. (1996) Discoveries: Architecture of The Renaissance, Harry N. Abrams

15.
Curl, J. S. (1992) Classical Architecture: An Introduction to its Vocabulary and essetials, with A Select Glossary of Term, London: B T Batsford Ltd

16.
Hersey, G. (1998) The Lost Meaning of Classical Architecture, Cambridge MA. : MIT Press

17.
Wilson, C. St. John (1995) The Other Tradition of Modern Architecture: The Uncompleted Project, U.K. : ACADEMY GROUPE LTD