JOURNAL BROWSE
Search
Advanced SearchSearch Tips
Wind and solar energy: a comparison of costs and environmental impacts
facebook(new window)  Pirnt(new window) E-mail(new window) Excel Download
  • Journal title : Advances in Energy Research
  • Volume 4, Issue 2,  2016, pp.121-146
  • Publisher : Techno-Press
  • DOI : 10.12989/eri.2016.4.2.121
 Title & Authors
Wind and solar energy: a comparison of costs and environmental impacts
Carnevale, Ennio A.; Lombardi, Lidia; Zanchi, Laura;
 Abstract
This study is concerned with the analysis of two renewable technologies for electric energy production: wind energy and photovoltaic energy. The two technologies were assessed and compared by economic point of view, by using selected indicators characterized by a clear calculation approach, requirement of information easy to be collected, clear, but even complete, interpretation of results. The used economic indicators are Levelized Cost of Energy, abatement cost and fossil fuel saving specific cost; these last two specifically aimed at evaluating the different capabilities that renewable technologies have to cut down direct emissions and to avoid fossil fuel extraction. The two technologies were compared also from the environmental point of view by applying Life Cycle Assessment approach and using the environmental impact categories from the Eco-indicator`95 method. The economic analysis was developed by taking into account different energy system sizes and different geographic areas in order to compare different European conditions (Italy, Germany and Denmark) in term of renewable resource availability and market trend. The environmental analysis was developed comparing two particular types of PV and wind plants, respectively residential and micro-wind turbine, located in Italy. According to the three calculated economic indicators, the wind energy emerged as more favorable than PV energy. From the environmental point of view, both the technologies are able to provide savings for almost all the considered environmental impact categories. The proposed approach, based on the use of economic and environmental indicators may be useful in supporting the policies and the decision making procedures concerned with the promotion and use of renewables, in reference to the specific geographic, economic and temporal conditions.
 Keywords
renewables;wind energy;photovoltaic;economics;Life Cycle Assessment;
 Language
English
 Cited by
 References
1.
Al-Behadili, S.H. and El-Osta, W.B. (2015), "Life cycle assessment of dernah (Libya) wind farm", Renew. Energy, 83, 1227-33. crossref(new window)

2.
Ardente, F., Beccali, M., Cellura, M. and Brano, V. L. (2008), "Energy performances and life cycle assessment of an italian wind farm", Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 12(1), 200-217. crossref(new window)

3.
Branker, K., Pathak, M.J.M. and Pearce, J.M. (2011), "A review of solar photovoltaic levelized cost of electricity", Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 15(9), 4470-82. crossref(new window)

4.
Carnevale, E., Carrozza, P., Ferroni, G.C., Ferrari, G.F., Morbidelli, G. and Orru, R. (2014), "Verso una politica energetica integrata. Le energie rinnovabili nel prisma della comparazione", Vol. 1, Editoriale Scientifica.

5.
Carnevale, E., Lombardi, L. and Zanchi, L. (2014), "Life cycle assessment of solar energy systems: comparison of photovoltaic and water thermal heater at domestic scale", Energy, 77, 434-46. crossref(new window)

6.
Cartografia di base DEAGOSTINI (2015), "Atlante Eolico Interattivo", http://atlanteeolico.rseweb.it/viewer.htm.

7.
de Wild-Scholten, M.J., Alsema, E.A., Ter Horst, E.W., Bachler, M. and Fthenakis, V.M. (2006), "A cost and environmental impact comparison of grid-connected rooftop and ground-based PV systems", Proceedings of the 21st European Photovoltaic Solar Energy Conference, 3167-73.

8.
ENEA (2011), "Quaderno. Energia Eolica", http://www.enea.it/it/comunicare-la-ricerca/documenti/quadernienergia/energiaeolica.pdf.

9.
ENEA (2015), "Atlante Italiano Della Radiazione Solare", http://www.solaritaly.enea.it/.

10.
EurObserv'ER (2014), The State of Renewable Energies in Europe, 14th EurObserv'ER Report, http://www.eurobserv-er.org/pdf/annual-overview-2014-en/.

11.
European Commission (2010), "COM (2010) 639 Final 'Communication from the commission to the European parliament, the council, the European economic and social committee and the commi ttee of the regions enrrgy 2020", A Strategy for Competitive, Sustainable and Secure Energy.

12.
European Commission (2013), "COM(2013) 196 Final: 'Communication from the commission to the European parliament and the council", Building the Single Market for Green Products Facilitating Better Information on the Environmental Performance of Products and Organisations.

13.
European Commission, Joint Research Centre, and Institute for Environment and Sustainability (2011), International Reference Life Cycle Data System (ILCD) Handbook, Recommendations for Life Cycle Impact Assessment in the European Context, First edition vols., Publications Office, Luxembourg.

14.
European Environment Agency (2015), "$CO_{2}$ (g) per KWh in 2009 (electricity Only)", http://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/figures/co2-electricity-g-per-kwh#tab-european-data.

15.
European Photovoltaic Industry Association (2011), "Solar Generation 6. Solar Photovoltaic Electricity Empowering the World", http://www.epia.org/uploads/tx_epiapublications/Solar_Generation_6__2011_Full_report_Final.pdf.

16.
European Solar Thermal Technology Panel of the European Technology Platform on Renewable Heating and Cooling (RHC-Platform). Strategic Research Priorities for Solar Thermal Technology (2012), http://www.rhc-platform.org/fileadmin/Publications/Solar_Thermal_SRP_single_page.pdf.

17.
Fthenakis, V.M. and Kim, H.C. (2011a), "Photovoltaics: life-cycle analyses", Prog. Sol. Energy, 85(8), 1609-28. crossref(new window)

18.
Fthenakis, V.M., Kim, H.C., Frischknecht, R., Raugei, M., Sinha, P. and Stucki, M. (2011b), "Life cycle inventories and life cycle assessment of photovoltaic systems", International Energy Agency (IEA) PVPS Task 12, Report T12-02:2011.

19.
Garrett, P. and Ronde, K. (2011), "Life cycle assessment of electricity production from a V100-1.8 MW gridstreamer wind plant", Vestas Wind Systems A/S, Randers, Dnemark.

20.
Goedkoop, M. (2012), "The Eco-Indicator 95", Final Report 353194/1711, PRe consultants.

21.
Graus, W. and Worrell, E. 2009), "Trend in efficiency and capacity of fossil power generation in the EU", Energy Policy, 37(6), 2147-60. crossref(new window)

22.
Guezuraga, B., Zauner, R. and Polz, W. (2012), "Life cycle assessment of two different 2 MW class wind turbines", Renew. Energy, 37(1), 37-44. crossref(new window)

23.
Gurzenich, D., Mathur, J., Bansal, N.K. and Wagner, H.J. (1999), "Cumulative energy demand for selected renewable energy technologies", Int. J. Life Cycle Assess., 4(3), 143-49. crossref(new window)

24.
Hang, Y., Qu, M. and Zhao, F. (2012), "Economic and environmental life cycle analysis of solar hot water systems in the United States", Energy Build., 45, 181-88. crossref(new window)

25.
Held, M. (2009), "Life cycle assessment of CdTe module recycling", Proceeding of the 24th EU PVSEC Conference, Hamburg, Germany.

26.
Hunkeler, D., Lichtenvort, K., Rebitzer, G., Ciroth, A. and SETAC-Europe, eds. (2008), Environmental Life Cycle Costing, CRC Press, Pensacola, Fl, Boca Raton.

27.
IRENA (2012a), Renewable Energy Technologies: Cost Analysis Series. Solar Photovoltaics, Volume 1: Power Sector, Issue 4/5, International Renewable Energy Agency.

28.
IRENA (2012b), Renewable Energy Technologies: Cost Analysis Series. Wind Power, Volume 1: Power Sector, Issue 5/5, International Renewable Energy Agency.

29.
IRENA (2012c), Summary for Policy Makers: Renewable Power Generation Costs, International Renewable Energy Agency.

30.
ISO 14040 (2006), Environmental Management-Life Cycle Assessment-Principles and Framework.

31.
ISO/TS 14067 (2013), Greenhouse Gases-Carbon Footprint of Products-Requirements and Guidelines for Quantification and Communication, http://www.iso.org/iso/catalogue_detail?csnumber=59521.

32.
Jungbluth, N., Stucki, M. and Frischknecht, R. (2009), "Photovoltaic. In Dones, R., (Ed.) et alI., Sachbilanzen von Energiesystemen: Grundlagen Fur Den okologischen Vergleich von Energiesystem Und Den Einbezung von Energiesystem in Okobilazen Fur Die Schiweiz", Ecoinvent Report No. 6-XII, Swiss Center for Life Cycle Inventories, Dubendorf, Switzerland.

33.
Kabakian, V., McManus, M.C. and Harajli, H. (2015), "Attributional life cycle assessment of mounted 1.8 kWp monocrystalline photovoltaic system with batteries and comparison with fossil energy production system", Appl. Energy, 154, 428-37. crossref(new window)

34.
Kabir, M.R., Rooke, B., Dassanayake, G.M. and Fleck, B.A. (2012), "Comparative life cycle energy, emission, and economic analysis of 100 kW nameplate wind power generation", Renew. Energy, 37(1), 133-41. crossref(new window)

35.
Koroneos, C.J. and Nanaki, E.A. (2012), "Life cycle environmental impact assessment of a solar water heater", J. Clean. Product., 37, 154-61. crossref(new window)

36.
Lang, P. (2011), "$CO_{2}$ abatement cost with electricity generation options in Australia", Citeseer, http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.361.1528&rep=rep1&type=pdf.

37.
Marimuthu, C. and Kirubakaran, V. (2013), "Carbon pay back period for solar and wind energy project installed in India: a critical review", Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 23, 80-90. crossref(new window)

38.
Martinez, E., Sanz, F., Pellegrini, S., Jimenez, E. and Blanco, J. (2009), "Life cycle assessment of a multimegawatt wind turbine", Renew. Energy, 34(3), 667-73. crossref(new window)

39.
Muller, A., Wambach, K. and Alsema, E. (2006), "Life cycle analysis of solar module recycling process", Materials Research Society 0895-G03-07.1.

40.
National Renewable Energy Laboratory (2015), NREL: Energy Analysis - Levelized Cost of Energy Calculator, http://www.nrel.gov/analysis/tech_lcoe.html.

41.
Nawaz, I. and Tiwari, G.N. (2006), "Embodied energy analysis of photovoltaic (PV) system based on Macro- and Micro-Level", Energy Policy, 34(17), 3144-52. crossref(new window)

42.
Nuclear Energy Agency (2005), International Energy Agency. Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development, Projected Costs of Generating Electricity, 2005 Update, https://inis.iaea.org/search/search.aspx?orig_q=RN:37044263.

43.
Pandey, D., Agrawal, M. and Pandey, J.S. (2010), "Carbon footprint: current methods of estimation", Environ. Monit. Assess., 178(1-4), 135-60.

44.
Peng, J., Lu, L. and Yang, H. (2013), "Review on life cycle assessment of energy payback and greenhouse gas emission of solar photovoltaic systems", Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 19, 255-74. crossref(new window)

45.
Raugei, M., Bargigli, S. and Ulgiati, S. (2007), "Life cycle assessment and energy pay-back time of advanced photovoltaic modules: CdTe and CIS compared to poly-Si", Energy, 3, 1310-1318.

46.
REN21 (2012), Renewables 2012 Global Status Report, Paris: REN21 Secretariat, http://www.ren21.net/Portals/0/documents/Resources/GSR2012_low%20res_FINAL.pdf.

47.
Riccardo, B. and Corrado, A. (2005), "Evaluation of technical improvements of photovoltaic systems through life cycle assessment methodology", Energy, 30(7), 952-67. crossref(new window)

48.
Schau, E.M., Traverso, M. Lehmann, A. and Finkbeiner, M. (2011), "Life cycle costing in sustainability assessment-a case study of remanufactured alternators", Sustainability, 3(12), 2268-88. crossref(new window)

49.
Short, W., Packey, D.J., Holt, T. and National Renewable Energy Laboratory (1995), A Manual for the Economic Evaluation of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Technologies, University Press of the Pacific, http://large.stanford.edu/publications/coal/references/troughnet/market/docs/5173.pdf.

50.
Turconi, R., Boldrin, A. and Astrup, T. (2013), "Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) of electricity generation technologies: overview, comparability and limitations", Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 28, 555-65. crossref(new window)

51.
Vargas, A.V., Zenon, E., Oswald, U., Islas, J.M., Guereca, L.P. and Manzini, F.L. (2015), "Life cycle assessment: a case study of two wind turbines used in Mexico", Appl. Therm. Eng., 75, 1210-16. crossref(new window)

52.
Wesselink, B. and Deng, Y. (2009), "Sectoral emission reduction potentials and economic costs for climate change (SERPEC-CC)", Summary Report, Ecofys.

53.
Xue, B., Ma, Z., Geng, Y., Heck, P., Ren, W., Tobias, M., Maas, A., Jiang, P., Puppim de Oliveira, J.A. and Fujita, T. (2015), "A life cycle co-benefits assessment of wind power in China", Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 41, 338-46. crossref(new window)