JOURNAL BROWSE
Search
Advanced SearchSearch Tips
A Comparative Study between Five Minds Mutual Restriction Therapy and Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy (STDP)
facebook(new window)  Pirnt(new window) E-mail(new window) Excel Download
  • Journal title : Journal of Oriental Neuropsychiatry
  • Volume 27, Issue 2,  2016, pp.57-65
  • Publisher : The Korean Society of Oriental Neuropsychiatry
  • DOI : 10.7231/jon.2016.27.2.057
 Title & Authors
A Comparative Study between Five Minds Mutual Restriction Therapy and Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy (STDP)
Jeong, Seon-Yeong; Kim, Jae-Yeong; Cho, Myoung-Ui; Kho, Young-Tak;
  PDF(new window)
 Abstract
Objectives The aim of this study was to develop a new Korean psychotherapeutic model in terms of emotion.Methods We compared the five minds mutual restriction therapy with short-term dynamic psychotherapy (STDP). We summarized 4 similarities and 4 differences of these two models of psychotherapy.Results 1. Short-term dynamic psychotherapy (STDP) needs active intervention of the therapist, with a restricted therapeutic focus and session. It blends with the present state of oriental neuropsychiatric clinics, and is suitable for Korean medical psychiatrists to apply short-term dynamic psychotherapy (STDP) to their clinical settings. 2. Short-term dynamic psychotherapy (STDP) and five minds mutual restriction therapy are similar, in that they both mainly use the emotions, needing restricted therapeutic focus and sessions, and active intervention of the therapist. 3. Short-term dynamic psychotherapy (STDP) and five minds mutual restriction therapy are different in their methods of arousing therapeutic emotion, the necessity of the patient being unconscious, the standard of patient selection, and the importance of follow up.Conclusions It is necessary to develop a new Korean psychotherapeutic model, which amalgamates the advantages of both methods of psychotherapy, and considers the present state of clinic. It is necessary that the Korean medical psychiatrists introspect themselves, since they are not merely therapists but also a role model for the patient.
 Keywords
Korean medical psychotherapy;Five minds mutual restriction therapy;Short-term dynamic psychotherapy (STDP);Emotion;Corrective emotional experience.;
 Language
Korean
 Cited by
 References
1.
The textbook compilation committee of neuropsychiatry of oriental medical schools in nation. The neuropsychiatry of oriental medicine. Revised edition. Seoul: Jipmoondang. 2010:655, 725.

2.
Kwon BH, Ku BS. A study of clinical document on relation to neuropsychiatric disease(Focusing on ancient chinese Song, Keum, Won, Myung clinical document). Journal of korean neuropsychiatric association. 1997;8(1):215-35.

3.
Kwon BH, Ku BS. A study of clinical document on relation to neuropsychiatric disease(Focusing on ancient chinese Qing clinical document). Journal of korean neuropsychiatric association. 1998;9(2):131-60.

4.
Oh JG. Integrative approach for theories of individual psychotherapies. The Journal of clinical research of Gongju national hospital. 2013;1:173-87.

5.
Lee SG. A comparative study on the psychotherapies between western and oriental Medicine. Journal of korean neuropsychiatric association. 2010;21(1):145-57.

6.
Yi JN. A Basic Study on the Introduction of Philosophical Counseling to Korea -A Suggestion for terminology readjustment and Organization-. Journal of Bumhan philosophical society. 2009;52:331-64.

7.
Kin JH. Integration art therapy counselling study based at the theory of transactional analysis. Journal of study on integrated art therapy. 2011;1(1):95-118.

8.
Huh RG. Humanities Healing in era of loss of self. Philosophy and reality. 2012;94:49-60.

9.
Koo BS. A psychotherapy of oriental medicine - focus on psychoanalysis-. Journal of korean neuropsychiatric association. 2003;14(2):1-14.

10.
Lee SG. Cognitive therapy and oriental psychotherapy. Journal of korean neuropsychiatric association. 2000;11(2):169-75.

11.
Paik YS. Psychoanalytic therapy - principles and application -. Wonkwang psychiatry. 1991;7(2):80-7.

12.
Min SK. Modern psychiatry. Fifth edition. Seoul:Ilchokak. 2013:693, 698.

13.
Yoon SI. Theory and practice of contemporary counseling psychotherapy. First edition. Seoul:Joongaangjuksung publication. 1995:559, 562-7.

14.
Korean neuropsychiatric association. Neuropsychiatry. First edition. Seoul:Hana medical publication. 1997:683.

15.
Paik YS. A case study of brief dynamic psychotherapy : a middle school pupil who often had difficulty sustaining attention while studying. Wonkwang psychiatry. 1995;11(2):29-73.

16.
Hwang IK. A stress management strategy -psychodynamic approach-. Psychosomatic medicine. 1995;3(1):58-63.

17.
Jang HH, Lyu YS, Kang HW. A review of the traditional concept of psychologic therapy in oriental medicine - specially about oh-Ji-Sang-Seung therapy -. Journal of korean neuropsychiatric association. 2001;12(1):11-27.

18.
Kwon BH, Ku BS. A study of clinical document on relation to neuropsychiatric disease(focusing on ancient chinese Song, Keum, Won, Myung clinical document). Journal of korean neuropsychiatric association. 1997;8(1):215-35.

19.
Hue YT. Study on medical records related to neuropsychiatric disorders in Mingyi-leian. College of oriental medicine graduate school of Dongguk university master's thesis. 2007.

20.
Kwon BH. Study on purgation theory of Yumunsachin and the case records. Journal of korean neuropsychiatric association. 1999;10(1):179-204.

21.
Lee JS. Debate short term psychotherapy. Psychotherapy. 1988;2(1):46-7.

22.
Lee DS. The tao and empathy : East asian interpretation. Korean journal of psychotherapy. 1993;7(1):7-19.