Publisher : Korea Institute of Ocean Science & Technology
DOI : 10.4217/OPR.2005.27.3.323
Title & Authors
A Policy Direction of Vessel Buyback Program for Coastal and Offshore Fisheries in Korea Pyo, Hee-Dong; Kwon, Suk-Jae;
The paper is to serve as a guide for deciding on a desirable direction for the vessel buyback program, reviewing their performance and economic effects from fish harvest reduction due to not reaching MSY. Compared with maximum willingness to pay for vessel buyback programs designed to avoid economic losses occurring as a result of overfishing, the portions of investment costs for buyback program are so small comparatively to the range of 0.32% to 12.19% at the annual base. The economic loss effects occurred in terms of the reduction of fishing harvest are comprehensively estimated at the present value of 30,877 billion won since 1971, and exceeded the revenues for fish harvests from 1999. In order to resole fish stocks through a vessel buyback program, this paper recommends that the yield should be reduced to less than the intrinsic growth rate. Otherwise, the buyback program policy eventually fails regardless of the temporal effect of benefits. This paper further argues that technical policy tools such as fishing grounds, fishing seasons, size of fish and minimum size of meshes should be effectively utilized.
vessel buyback programs;economic loss of fish harvest;critical value;Maximum Sustainable Yield:MSY;
Anderson, L.G. 1985. Potential economic benefits from gear restrictions and license Limitation in Fisheries Regulation. Land Econ., 61(4), 409-418.
Campbell, H.F. 1989. Fishery buy-back programs and economic welfare. Aust. J. Agr. Econ., 33(1), 20-31.
Campbell, H.F. and R.K. Linder. 1990. The production of fishing effort and the economic performance of licence limitation programs. Land Econ., 66(1), 56-66.
Conrad, J.M. 1999. Resource economics. Cambridge University Press. p. 49-57.
Guyader, O. and F. Daures. 2000. Economic analysis of the impact of buyback programs and the role of financial incentives schemes: Application to French fishery sector. IIFET(International Institute of Fisheries Economics and Trade) 2000, July 10-14, Corvallis, Oregon, USA.
Holland, D., E. Gudmundsson, and J. Gates. 1999. Do fishing vessel buyback programs work: A survey of the evidence. Mar. Policy, 23(1), 47-69.
Sun, C.H. 1999. Optimal number of fishing vessels for Taiwan’s offshore fisheries: A comparison of different fleet size reduction policies. Mar. Resour. Econ., 13, 275-288.
Walden, J.B., J.E. Kirkley, and A.W. Kitts. 2003. A limited economic assessment of the northeast groundfish fishery buyout program. Land Econ., 79(3), 426-439.
Weninger, Q. and K.E. McConnell. 2000. Buyback programs in commercial fisheries: Efficiency versus Transfers. Can. J. Econ., 33(2), 394-412.