JOURNAL BROWSE
Search
Advanced SearchSearch Tips
Step-by-step Participatory Design Process through Construction of Public Discourse and Community Development - An Analysis of New York Governors Island Park and Public Spaces -
facebook(new window)  Pirnt(new window) E-mail(new window) Excel Download
 Title & Authors
Step-by-step Participatory Design Process through Construction of Public Discourse and Community Development - An Analysis of New York Governors Island Park and Public Spaces -
Choi, Hyeyoung; Pae, Jeong-Hann;
  PDF(new window)
 Abstract
This study, which takes the New York Governors Island project as an example, is an in-depth analysis of the process of participatory design for transforming a space that had long been isolated from the public into a park and/or communal space. We found that the process of participatory design at each project phase consists of the following. First, in the preparatory phase, there was construction of public discourse: efforts to find a consensus to develop the space in a public-driven direction was led by various initiatives. Second, by opening the site to the public before the design phase and by consistently inviting a wide range of activities, a community was formed and its attachment to the site was established. Third, after the competition until the completion of the project master planning phase, substantial and active participatory design was enabled through social interaction of the community formed and developed over many years. Fourth, in the detail design and implementation phase, a traditional and passive way of participatory design such as public hearings was used, thereby preserving the expertise of professional designers. Public participation was reflected most in the master planning phase to create a broad framework of the park, while professionals designed the more specific aspects; this efficient and effective approach enabled both citizens and professionals to dutifully take part in developing the park. The results of this study can be summarized as follows. The mode of participatory design should be varied at each project phase, from construction of public discourse, to formation and development of the community, to participatory design for social interaction. Furthermore, it is effective to preserve the unique roles of citizens and design professionals. It is particularly important to extend the process of participatory design to include the construction of public discourse and community.
 Keywords
Project Phase;Public Participation;Social Interaction;
 Language
Korean
 Cited by
1.
거버넌스를 통한 대형 도시공원의 조성 및 운영관리 전략 - 프레시디오 공원과 시드니 하버 국립공원 사례를 중심으로 -,심주영;조경진;

한국조경학회지, 2016. vol.44. 6, pp.60-72 crossref(new window)
2.
가상현실(VR)을 활용한 참여형 공간설계방법론,최재연;김은형;

지적과 국토정보, 2016. vol.46. 2, pp.253-267 crossref(new window)
 References
1.
Arendt, H.(1958) Human Condition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

2.
DiNapoli, T. P.(2006) Governors Island Preservation and Education Corporation Management of the Governors Island Redevelopment Process Report 2005-S-43, Office of the New York State Comptroller, Division of State Government Accountability.

3.
GIPEC(2006a) Governors Island Land Use Improvement and Civic Project General Project Plan.

4.
GIPEC(2006b) Public Open Space Professional Design Services: Governors Island, New York City, Request for Statements of Qualification.

5.
GIPEC(2007a) Public Open Space Professional Design Services: Governors Island, New York City, Request for Proposals.

6.
GIPEC(2007b) Governors Island Preliminary Design Guidelines.

7.
GIPEC(2009) Governors Island Park Master Plan Public Outreach Summary.

8.
GIPEC/West8 Team(2010) Governors Island Park and Public Space Master Plan.

9.
Governors Island Alliance(2006) Governors Island: Guidelines for Parks and Public Spaces.

10.
Habermas, J.(1991) The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: An Inquiry into a Category of Bourgeois Society. Thomas Burger, Frederick Lawrence, trans., Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

11.
Hillery, G. A.(1955) Definitions of community: Areas of agreement. Rural Sociology 20(2):111-123.

12.
Junichi, S.(2009) Democratic Publicness. Yoon, D. S., Ryu, S. Y., Yoon, M. R., trans., Seoul: E-UM.

13.
Kim, S. B. and G. H. Kim(2012) Realizing publicness with discourse and participation on architectural design process in the case of seattle public library. Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea Planning & Design 28(2): 131-138.

14.
Kim, W. D., M. Y. Kim and J. W. Choi(2008) A basic study on development of the community participation design tool for urban regeneration. Proceeding of Annual Conference of the Architectural Institute of Korea 28(1): 85-88.

15.
Kim, Y. G. and K. M. Lee(2003) A study on landscape architecture planning and design as communicative action. Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 31(5): 73-85.

16.
Kim, Y. G., J. S. Sung, S. M. Cho and K. M. Lee(2003) Community participatory small park design. Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 31(1): 78-89.

17.
Office of Deputy Mayor for Economic Development(2011) Phased Redevelopment of Governors Island Final Generic Environmental Impact Statement-Project Description.

18.
Park, J. H., Y. H. Son and K. Tsuge(2011) Participatory design process for the utilization of the military relocation site -The case of the idea competition for the Fukaya communication site in Yokohama-. Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 39(3): 10-25.

19.
Trust for Governors Island(2014a) Governors Island Visitorship.

20.
Trust for Governors Island(2014b) All Event Partners 2008-2014.

21.
Trust for Governors Island(2014c) Outreach Slides and Hammock Story.

22.
United States of America General Services Administration(2003a) Quitclaim Deed to National Trust for Historic Preservation.

23.
United States of America General Services Administration(2003b) Quitclaim Deed to GIPEC.

24.
VanAlen Fellowship in PublicArchitecture(1996) Competition for Governors Island, New York Harbor.

25.
Wates, N.(2006) The Community Planning Handbook. London: Earthscan.

26.
http://govisland.com/ (2015년 5월 검색)

27.
http://vanalen.org/projects/public-property-an-ideas-competition-forgovernors-island/ (2015년 5월 검색)

28.
http://www.figmentproject.org/figment_history (2015년 12월 검색)

29.
http://www.govislandblog.com (2015년 5월 검색)

30.
http://www.nps.gov/gois/index.htm (2015년 5월 검색)