Advanced SearchSearch Tips
Comparison of SWAT-K and HSPF for Hydrological Components Modeling in the Chungju Dam Watershed
facebook(new window)  Pirnt(new window) E-mail(new window) Excel Download
 Title & Authors
Comparison of SWAT-K and HSPF for Hydrological Components Modeling in the Chungju Dam Watershed
Kim, Nam-Won; Shin, Ah-Hyun; Kim, Chul-Gyum;
  PDF(new window)
SWAT-K model is a modified version of the original SWAT, and is known to more accurately estimate the streamflows and pollutant loadings in Korean watersheds. In this study, its hydrological components were compared with those of HSPF in order to analyse the differences in total runoff including evapotranspiration(ET), surface flow, lateral flow and groundwater flow from the Chungju Dam watershed during . Averaged annual runoff with SWAT-K overestimated by 1%, and HSPF underestimated it by 3% than observed runoff. Determination coefficients() for observed and simulated daily streamflows by both the models were relatively good(0.80 by SWAT-K and 0.82 by HSPF). Potential ET and actual ET by HSPF were lower in winter, but similar or higher than those by SWAT-K. And though there were some differences in lateral and groundwater flows by two models because of the differences in hydrological algorithms, the results were to be reasonable. From the results, it was suggested that we should utilize a proper model considering the characteristic of study area and purposes of the model application because the simulated results from same input data could be different with models used. Also we should develop a novel model appropriate to Korean watersheds by enhancing limitations of the existing models in the future.
Comparison models;HSPF;Hydrological component;SWAT-K;
 Cited by
매개변수 보정 전문가시스템을 이용한 HSPF 모형의 수문 매개변수 보정 및 적용성 평가,김성민;김상민;

한국농공학회논문집, 2013. vol.55. 4, pp.13-20 crossref(new window)
유역 유출량 추정을 위한 TANK 모형의 매개변수 최적화에 따른 적용성 평가,김계웅;송정헌;안지현;박지훈;전상민;송인홍;강문성;

한국농공학회논문집, 2014. vol.56. 4, pp.9-19 crossref(new window)
한국건설기술연구원, 2007, 지표수 수문성분 해석 시스템 개발 , 2단계 연구보고서, 384

윤춘경, 신아현, 정광욱, 장재호, 2007, BASINS/WinHSPF를 이용한 남한강 상류유역의 비점오염원 저감효율평가, 수질보전 한국물환경학회지, 23(6), 951-960

임상준, Brannan K. M., Mostaghimi S., 조재필, 2003, HSPF와 SWAT 모형을 이용한 산림유역의 유출 및 유사량 추정, 한국농촌계획학회논문집, 9(4), 59-64

손경호, 이혜숙, 김정곤, 2006, SWAT과 HSPE 모델을 이용한 용담댐 유역 유출량과 유사량 분석, 공동추계학술발표회 논문집, 대한상하수도학회.한국물환경학회, 738-746

Singh J., Knapp H. V., Arnold J. G., Demissie M., 2004, Hydrological Modeling of the Iroquois River Watershed Using HSPF and SWAT, Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 41(2), 343-360 crossref(new window)

Nasr A., Bruen M., Jordan P., Moles R, Kiely G., Byrne P., 2007, A comparison of SWAT, HSPF and SHETRAN/GOPC for modelling phosphorus export from three catchments in Ireland, Water research, 41(5), 1065-1073 crossref(new window)

Saleh A., Du B., 2004, Evaluation of SWAT and HSPF within BASINS Program for the Upper North Bosque River Watershed in Central Texas, Journal of American Society of Agricultural Engineers, 47(4), 1039-1050 crossref(new window)

Kim N. W., Chung 1. M., Won Y. S., Arnold, J. G., 2008, Development and application of the integrated SWAT-MODFLOW model, Journal of hydrology, 356( 1/2), 1-16 crossref(new window)

Kim N. W., Lee J., 2008, Temporally weighted average curve number method for daily runoff simulation, Hydrological Processes, 22, 4936-4948 crossref(new window)

Allen R. G., 1986, A Penman for all seasons, J. Irr. Drainage Eng. (ASCE), 112(4), 348-368 crossref(new window)

Allen R G., Jensen M. E., Wright J. L., Burman R. D., 1989, Operational estimates of evapotranspiration, Agron. J., 81, 650-662 crossref(new window)

Monteith J. L., 1965, Evaporation and environment. In The State and Movement of Water in Living Organisms, Proceedings of 15th Symposium Society for Experimental Biology, Swansea. Cambridge University Press, London, 205-234

Priestley C. H. B., Taylor R. J., 1972, On the assessment of surface heat flux and evaporation using large-scale parameters, Month. Weather Revision, 100, 81-92 crossref(new window)

Hargreaves G. L., Hargreaves G. H., Riely J. P., 1985, Agriculture benefits for Senegal River Basin, J. Irr. Drainage Eng. (ASCE), 111(2), 113-124 crossref(new window)

Jensen M. E., Haise H. R., 1963, Estimating evapotranspiration from solar radiation: Proceedings of the American Society of Civil Engineers, Journal of Irrigation and Drainage, 89(4) 15-41

Hamon R. W., 1961, Estimating Potential Evapotranspiration, Proceedings of the American Society of Civil Engineers, Journal of the Hydraulic Division, 87(HY3), 107-120

유승환, 최진용, 장민원, 2006, 논벼에 대한 Penman-Monteith와 FAO Modified Penman 공식의 작물 계수 산정, 한국농공학회논문집, 48(1), 13-23

Di Luzio M., Srinivasan R, Arnold J., 2001, Arcview Interface for SWAT2000 User's Guide, TWRl Report TR-193, Texas Water Resources Institute, College Station, TX

Neitsch S. L., Arnold J. G., Kiniry J. R., Williams J. R., 2001, Soil and Water Assessment Tool; the theoretical documentation (version 2000, U. S. Agricultural Research Service)

Bicknell B. R., Imhoff 1. C., Kittle Jr., J. L., Jobes T. H., Donigian Jr., A. S., 2001, Hydrological Simulation Program - FORTRAN (HSPF): User's manual for Version 12, U.S.EPA, Environmental Research Laboratory, Athens, GA

Hooghoudt S. B., 1940, Bijdage tot de kennis van enige natuurkundige grootheden van de grond, Versl. Landbouwkd. Onderz., 46, 515-707

김철겸, 이정은, 김남원, 2007, 충주댐 상류유역의 유사 발생에 대한 시공간적인 특성, 한국수자원학회논문집, 40(11), 887-898 crossref(new window)

김남원, 이병주, 이정은, 2007, 공간모의유량을 이용한 갈수량 거동 특성에 관한 연구, 대한토목학회논문집, 27(4B), 431-440

김철겸, 김남원, 2008, 충주댐 유역의 오염원에 따른 오염부하량 발생 특성, 수질보전 한국물환경학회지, 24(4), 465-472

Nash J. E., Sutcliffe J. V., 1970, River flow forecasting through conceptual model, Journal of Hydrology, 10(3), 282-290 crossref(new window)

김남원, 이정우, 이병주, 이정은, 2007, 비선형 저류 방정식을 이용한 일 단위 하도추적법, 대한토목학회논문집, 27(5B), 533-542

Jensen M. E., Rob D. C. N., Franzoy C. E., 1969, Scheduling irrigations using climate-crop-soil data, National Conference on Water Resources Engineering of the American Society of Civil Engineers, New Orleans, LA

Leavesley G. H., Lichty R. W., Troutman B. M., Saindon L. G., 1983, Precipitation Runoff Modeling System: User's Manual, Water Resources Investigations 83-4238, U.S. Geological Survey, Denver, CO

Nathan R J., McMahon T. A., 1990, Evaluation of automated techniques for baseflow and recession analyses, Water Resources Research, 26(7), 1465-1473

건설교통부, 2007, 우리나라 지역특성에 맞는 최적지하수 함양량 산정 기법 개발,66