참조응력법에 입각한 T-배관 국부 크리프 파단 평가를 위한 응력해석 사례연구

Reference Stress Based Stress Analysis for Local Creep Rupture of a T-pipe

  • 신규인 (중앙대학교 미래신기술연구소) ;
  • 윤기봉 (중앙대학교 기계공학부) ;
  • 김윤재 (고려대학교 기계공학부)
  • 발행 : 2006.08.01


To investigate applicability of the reference stress approach as simplified inelastic stress analysis to estimate local creep rupture, detailed finite element stress analyses of a T-piece pipe with different inner pressure and system loading levels are performed. The reference stresses are obtained from the finite element (FE) limit analysis based on elastic-perfectly-plastic materials, from which the local reference stress for creep rupture is determined from R5. The resulting inelastic stresses are compared with elastic stresses resulting from linear elastic FE calculations. Furthermore they are also compared with the stresses from full elastic-creep FE analyses. It shows that the stresses estimated from the reference stress approach compare well with those from full elastic-creep FE analysis, which are significantly lower than the elastic stress results. Considering time and efforts for full inelastic creep analysis of structures, the reference stress approach is shown to be a powerful tool for creep rupture estimates and also to reduce conservatism of elastic stress analysis significantly.


  1. AI Laham, S., 1999, 'Large Bore Branch test Creep Analysis,' EPD/GEN/REP/0371/98
  2. Shard, P. a., Hurst, A. M. and Jagger, M., 1998, 'Hartlepool Power Station Defect Assessment of the Hot Reheat Crossover Branch Weld B2C/SR98F,' Task 34627
  3. Patel, R.D., 2003, 'Creep Life Assessment of Welded Trunnion and Branch Components Using the R5 Procedure,' Int, J. Pres. Ves, & Piping, Vol. 80, pp. 695-704
  4. Lee, H. Y., Soo, T. S. and Chong, C. H., 2000, 'Life Assessment of High Temperature T-joint with Semi-elliptical Surface Crack,' Annuals Conference of KSME, pp. 33-40
  5. Song, K. W., You, K. B., Hyun, S. R., Jang, S. H. and Ha, J. S., 2001, 'Damage Evaluation Technology of Main Steam Pipe Using 14MoV63,' Annuals Conference of KSME, pp. 146-151
  6. Wang, B., Hu, N., Kurobane, Y., Makino Y. and Lie, S. T., 2000, 'Damage Criterion and Safety Assessment Approach to Tubular Joints,' Engineering Fracture, Vol. 22, pp. 424-434
  7. Miroslmik, R, Shaked, Y. and Elmakis, D., 1997, 'Life Assessment Evaluation of Piping Branch Connection under Creep and Fatigue,' Int, J. Pres. Ves. & Piping, Vol. 71, pp. 147-154
  8. NRIM Creep Data Sheet, 1972, National Research fusitute for Mrtals
  9. ABAQUS Version 6.5, 2005, Hibbitt, Karlsson & Sorensen Inc
  10. Welding Handbook Vol. 1, 1987, American Welding Society
  11. Yoon, K. B., Lee, H. M., Nalun, S. H., Park, C. S., and Kim, S. C., 1994, 'Development of a Portable Metallographic Analysis System,' KRlSS-94-133-IR
  12. Yoon, K. B., Lee, H. M., Nalun, S. H., Kim, S. C. and Park, C. S., 'Precise Diagnosis and Life Assessment for Aged Power Plant : Youngwol Station 1,' KRlSS-93-171-HR