Assessment of Airborne Welding Fume Concentration for Some Manufacturing Industries in Busan

Cha, Min-Ho;Kim, Jeong-Won;Kim, Jong-Eun;Cho, Young-Ha;Moon, Deog-Hwan

  • Published : 2007.12.31


This study was conducted to describe the exposure levels of welding fumes by the type of manufacturers, work process, welding type and the size of manufacturers, and to find out the trend of chronological changes of airborne welding fume levels. The subjects of this study were 509 manufacturers, consisting of 11 types of manufacturers, 3 work processes, 7 welding types, in Busan from January, 1997 to December, 2005. Airborne concentration of welding fume was determined by manual of National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), and the data were analyzed by using SPSS 10.0 for Windows program. The mean concentration of airborne welding fume in all manufacturers was $1.29\;mg/m^3$ (Range: $0.01{\sim}3.00\;mg/m^3)$. The level of welding fume was the highest, as $1.96\;mg/m^3$, for manufactures of motor vehicles, trailers and semi-trailers, which was lower than $5.0\;mg/m^3$ of 8 hr-TWA in Korean permissible exposure limit for welding fume. There was a significant difference in the mean levels of welding fumes by work process, showing the highest in welding workshop ($1.39\;mg/m^3$), followed by pipeline welding workshop ($1.26\;mg/m^3$) and engineering workshop ($1.20\;mg/m^3$). Among welding types, the mean level of welding fume was the highest in the type of $CO_2$ & arc welding, as $1.46\;mg/m^3$, followed by $CO_2$ welding ($1.40\;mg/m^3$), shielded metal arc welding ($1.31\;mg/m^3$), spot welding ($1.27\;mg/m^3$), and so on. The highest mean level of welding fume was $1.58\;mg/m^3$ in work process of pipe line welding workshop for the manufacturers of basic iron and steel, and $2.27\;mg/m^3$ in the type of arc welding for the manufactures building ship and boats. By the size of manufacturers, the mean concentration of welding fume for manufactures in small scale with less than 50 workers was the highest as $1.45\;mg/m^3$ (Range: $0.07{\sim}3.00\;mg/m^3)$. The mean level of welding fume was the highest as $1.39\;mg/m^3$ both in 1997 and in 2005, showing a trend of fluctuating periodically within a range of $1.10{\sim}1.39\;mg/m^3$. The above results suggested that more effective control program for work environment producing welding fumes should be developed and applied since there were significant variations in welding fume levels by the type of manufacturers, work processes, welding types, the size of manufactures, and by year.


welding fume;manufacturers;welding type;work process;permissible exposure limit;chronological change


  1. Kwag, Y.S. and Paik, N.W. : A Study on airborne concentration of welding fumes and metals in confined spaces of a shipyard. Korean Industrial Hygiene Association Journal, 7(1), 113-31, 1997
  2. Ferry, J.J. and Ginther, G.B. : Inert arc welding. Industrial Hygiene Quarterly, 13(4), 196, 1952
  3. Zenz, C. : Occupational Medicine, 2nd ed., Chicago, Year Book Medical Publishers, Inc., 1988
  4. Kim, J.Y. : A Study on the Manganese Exposure and Health Hazard among Manganese Manufacturing Workers, Master's Dissertation, School of Public Health, Seoul National University, 1994
  5. Lee, C.U., Lee, J.T., Sohn, H.S., Bae, K.T. and Park, H.J. : An epidemiological study on pneumoconiosis of welders in shipyards in busan. Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health, 22(1), 153-161, 1989
  6. Phoon, W.H. and Tan, K.T. : Welding fumes in shipyards. Occupational Health and Safety, 2, 19-25, 1983
  7. Kim, K.J. and Song, K.C. : A study on the concentration of welding fume in a shipbuilding factory. Korean Industrial Hygiene Association Journal, 1(1), 68-72, 1991
  8. Kang, Y.S., Sirn, S.H., Lee, S.K., Bin, S.O. and Choi, E.S. : A comparison study on the concentration of total welding fume and respirable particulate mass for welding workers of a shipbuilding. Korean Journal of Environmental Health, 33(4), 276-282, 2007
  9. Reike, F.F. : Lead intoxication in shipbuilding and ship scrapping (1941-1968). Archives of Environmental Health, 19, 521-539, 1969
  10. Mogan, W.K.C. : On welding, wheezing and wimsy. American Industrial Hygiene Association Journal, 52(2), 59-69, 1989
  11. Kim, Y.H., Kim, J.W., Lim, H.S., Shin, Y.C. and Kim, K.S. : The Result of Proton Emitted Tomography (PET) for Welding Workers Suspected of Manganese Poisoning. Proceedings of the 19th Occupational Medicine Conference (Fall), the Korean Society of Occupational Medicine, 1997
  12. Byeon, S.H., Park, S.H., Kim, C.I., Park, I.J., Yang, J.S., Oh, S.M. and Moon, Y.H. : A Study on the airborne concentration of welding fume for some manufacturing industries. Korean Industrial Hygiene Association Journal, 5(2), 172-83, 1995
  13. Clayton, G.D. and F.E. : Patty's Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology, New York, A Wiley Interscience Publication 1, 1172-1178, 1997
  14. Meyer, E.C., Kratzinger, S.F. and Miller, W.H. : Pulmonary fibrosis in an arc welder. Archives of Environmental Health, 15, 463-469, 1967
  15. Stern, R.M., Piggott, G.H. and Abrahm, J.L. : Fibrogenic potential of welding fume. Journal of Applied Toxicology, 3, 18-30, 1983
  16. Shin, Y.C., Yi, Y.G., Park, S.H. Lee, N.R., Jeong, J.Y, Park, J.K., Oh, S.M. and Moon, Y.H. : A study on factors affecting airborne fume composition and concentration in welding process. Korean Industrial Hygiene Association Journal, 7(2), 181-195, 1997
  17. National Institute for Safety and Health (NIOSH) : NIOSH Method #0500, NIOSH Manual of Analytical Methods, 4th ed., NIOSH, Cincinati, OH : pp94-113, 1994
  18. Guiodott, T.L. : The higher oxides of Nitrogen : Inhalation toxicology. Environmental Research, 15, 443-472, 1978
  19. Cho, Y.S., Seo, H.S. and Park, H.S. : A case of occupational asthma in a metal arc welder. Journal of Korean Society of Allergy, 12(2), 218-221, 1992
  20. Korea National Statistical Office (KNSO) : Korean Standard Classification of Occupations (KSCO), KNSO, 2000
  21. Ministry of Labor: Permissible Exposure Limit for Chemicals and Physical Agents(Bulletin of the Ministry of Labor 2002-8), 2002.5.6: pp4-62, 2002
  22. Choi, H.C, Kim, K.Y., An, S.H., Park, W.M., Kim, S.J., Lee, Y.J. and Chang, K.C. : Airborne concentrations of welding fume and metals of workers exposed to welding fume. Korean Industrial Hygiene Association Journal, 9(1), 56-72, 1999
  23. Yoon, C.S., Park, D.W. and Park, D.Y. : A study on the content variation of metals in welding fumes. Korean Journal of Environmental Health Society. 28(2), 117-129, 2002
  24. Lee, K.S. and Paik, N.W. : Airborne concentrations of welding fume and metal components by type of welding. Korean Industrial Hygiene Association Journal, 4(1), 71-80, 1994
  25. Yoon, C.S. and Paik, N.W. : A study on the fume generation rates and particle size distributions at flux cored arc welding on stainless steel. Korean Journal of Environmental Health Society, 25(2), 107-114, 1999
  26. Ministry of Labor: Industrial Safety and Health Act, Ministry of Labor, 1994