An Analysis on Restructuring of Urban Fabric in Green City Planning in relation to quality of spaces, planning elements and performance indicator

저탄소 도시관리를 위한 도시공간조직의 재구조화 과정에 관한 연구

  • Yeom, In-Sup ;
  • Oh, Deog-Seong
  • 염인섭 ;
  • 오덕성
  • Received : 2013.07.03
  • Accepted : 2013.11.07
  • Published : 2014.02.28


This paper aims to identify the relationship and relative importance of the elements in a Green City planning, which are based on the spatial restructuring for qualities of urban form such as accessibility, efficiency, viability, security and amenity and the physical restructuring of the fabric and metabolism at various scale of urban system. What we find is that the linkage between quality of spaces in urban form and its planning elements (of a Green City) are generally complex and indirect. With these considerations, we find out the planning directions and practical lessons through pairwise comparison matrix of 'quality of spaces (Q)' and 'planning elements(G)' using the AHP(Analytic Hierarchy Process). Also, this paper describes how to define impact on restructuring of urban system by connection between quality based goals-quality of spaces (Q), strategy planning-planning elements (G) and performance indicator-planning indicator (T) in urban system by applying QFD(Quality Function Deployment) methodology. The analysis in this paper is completed by the following processes: i) extracting major components on quality of spaces(Q) the planning elements(G), ii) understanding the co-operative relationship or effects between them, iii) analyzing the relative importance of planning elements with relation to quality of spaces, iv) and then determining the impact on planning elements by performance indicator in relation to quality of spaces implicated in urban system. It thus draws implications for spatial and physical restructuring of urban system at various scale in the planning process for a Green City. Finally, it is very important for an urban system as an engine of a city to be tuned or re-engineered for greater efficiency with good match or linkage between planning elements in relation to its qualities of urban space.


Carbon Neutral City;Green City;Restructuring of urban system;AHP(Analytic Hierarchy Process);Quality Function Deployment method


  1. 강상준, 탄소저감을 위한 친환경 공간구성 방안, 경기개발연구원 (기본연구 2009-17), 경기개발연구원
  2. 구자훈, New Urbanism과 친환경도시의 도시계획적 실천방안, 대한국토도시계획학회 세미나 자료, 대한국토도시계획학회, 2008.3
  3. 김정곤, 최정은, 탄소중립도시 조성을 위한 도시계획전략 연구, 한국도시설계학회, 한국도시설계학회지<도시설계>제8권 제4호, 2011.4
  4. 반영운 외 5인, 기후변화에 대응한 국토 및 도시개발전략, 대한국토도시계획학회지 도시정보, 2008.9
  5. 변병설, 기후변화대응계획 지표개발 연구, 국토지이학회 국토지리학회지 43권 4호, 2009
  6. 왕광익, 유선철, 저탄소 녹색도시 조성을 위한 도시계획 수립 기준, 한국토지주택공사 토지주택연구원, <토지연구>제29권 통권 제87호 (2009년 제2호) p.p.65-88, 2009.2
  7. 오용준 외 4인, 저탄소 에너지 절약형 도시계획의 정책과제 및 추진전략, 충남발전연구원(기본과제), 2009.12
  8. 이재준, 한국형 생태도시 계획지표 개발에 관한 연구, 국토도시계획학회지 국토계획, 제40권 4호, 2005
  9. 한국토지주택공사, 저탄소 녹색도시 모델구상, 한국토지주택공사 토지주택연구원, 2009. 9
  10. Benninger C. (2001): "Principles of Intelligent Urbanism", in Ekistics, Volume 69, Number 412, pp.39-65, Athens.
  11. Girardet, H., The Gaia Atlas of Cities: New Directions for Sustainable Urban Living, Gaia Books, London, 1992
  12. Joe Ravetz, Integrated assesment for sustainability apprais al in cities and regions, Environmental Impact Assessment Review, Vol.20, p.p.35-36, Elsevier Science, 2000a
  13. Joe Ravetz, Urban Form and the Sustainability of Urban Systems : Theory and Practice in a Northern Conurbation, Achieving Sustainable Urban Form(Part 3), E&FN Spon, 2000b
  14. Mollison, B., and R.M. Slay. Introduction to Permaculture. Tyalgum, Australia: Tagari, 1991.
  15. Philine Gaffron, Ge Huismans, and Franz Skala, Ecocity' Urban Development towards Appropriate Structures for Su stainable Transport'(2002-2005) - Book 1 A better place t o live, European Commission, DG Research, 2005
  16. Simon Guy and Simon Marvin, Understanding Sustainable Cities: Competing Urban Futures European Urban and Regional Studies July 1999 6: 268-275
  17. Robson, B., Bradford, M., Deas, I., Hall, E., Harrison, E., P arkinson, M., Evans, R., Garside, P. and Harding, A.(1994) Assessing the Impact of Urban Policy, HMSO, London