Establish of Evaluation level in Public Management System using Policy Evaluation Framework in Urban Renewal Project

정책평가 틀을 이용한 도시정비사업 내 공공관리자제도의 평가기준 수립에 관한 연구

  • Received : 2015.05.29
  • Accepted : 2015.09.11
  • Published : 2015.09.30


This study targets to recognize needs of adopting public management system in Urban Renewal Project. and to establish evaluation level of public management system using policy evaluation framework for establishing perspective and systemic level. Also, this study constructed basic principles as expanded concept like Public, expertise, participation, rationality, and sustainability based on previous studies and expert opinion. AHP analysis results are following. In case of upper level, post management and continuity are important factors. Also in case of under level, making stable economic system, honest operating system, reducing development costs, local development with self-sufficiency were important factors. through empirical results, the implications are following. First, public management system needs to develop a consistent principle from planning step to post management. Second, it is essential point that continuous retraining between involved people and drawing residents participate in progress activity. Third, when evaluating public management system, it is need that emphasize non-physical factor like conflict issue between stakeholder.


Policy evaluation;Public management system;Urban Renewal Project;Analytic hierarchy process;Focus Group Interview


  1. Shin-Eun, Kang, The Study of implementation of the management disposal plan on legal system -in the housing redevelopment and rebuilding project, master's thesis, p.1-249, chungang university, 2012.
  2. Hee-soo, Park, "An analysis on the characteristic of the conflicts and public Interventions for the urban renewal projects", doctor's thesis. p.1-157, hanyang university, 2010.
  3. KwanSoo, Yang, "A study on the system of project manager In urban renewal", master's thesis. p.1-109, hanyang university, 2010.
  4. Housing department in Seoul Metropolitan Government, "Q&A about public management system in seoul housing," , Seoul Metropolitan Government,
  5. Yea-Cheol, Shin, Young-Gull, Kim, Ja-Hoon, Koo, "Development of Evaluation System for Public Design Policy as Urban Design - Focused on Evaluation for the Public Design Policy of Seoul", Journal of the Urban Institute of Korea 11(4), p.5-22, 2010.
  6. Jung-Soo, Lee, Dae-Jung,Kwon, "A Survey on the Consciousness of Landowners with the Implementation of the Public Management System -Focused on the Housing Redevelopment Project", Journal of Korea Real Estate Society 28(1), p. 239-262, 2010.
  7. Sung kyu, Doo, "Direction to improve system for activating resonable role of public management system", journal of Cooperation &economy Research Institute of Korea, p.1-23, 2010.
  8. Jong Seong, Kim, "A study on Improvement of he Public Management System in Urban Renewal Project : Focuses on Project District", master's thesis, p.1-179, hanyang university, 2012.
  9. Yong Kyeong, Eo, "A study on the promotion of public interest in the cite redevelopment policy : focused on public management system", master's thesis. p.1-106, hanyang university, 2010.
  10. Kwang-sub, Jung, "The development of evaluation models for assessing green performances of sustainable green cities", doctor's thesis. p.1-165, hanyang university, 2010.
  11. Sang won, kim, "developing evaluation factor for improving effective investment in protecting children area", Journal of the korea association for policy analysis and evaluation 19(2), p. 21-36, 2009.
  12. young-choon, kim, seung ho, shin, jung sook, kim, "An Empirical Study on the Factors of BSC Performances in the Public Sector", The e-Business Studies 8(4), p. 241-262, 2007.
  13. Ji ho, chun, "Overseas market entry strategies for new town development in public enterprise perspective", master's thesis, p.1-113, yonsei university, 2007.
  14. Won chul, lee, "Derivation study of urban-rehabilitation strategies and planning factors for waterfront areas in consideration of revitalization", doctor's thesis, p.1-179, hanyang university, 2014.
  15. Keun tae, jo, Sung jun, kim, Dae sick, kim, young woo, jo, jong in, lee, " Priority Setting for Future Core Technologies using the AHP - With Major Fields in Rural Development and Resources -",Journal of Korean Society of Rural Planning 9(3), p.41-46, 2003.
  16. Sung yeon, kim, "Study of Public Management System on Housing Redevelopment Program through Principal-Agent Theory", journal of housing studies 19(4), p.1-21, 2011.
  17. Dong-ryul, Lee, " The Study on the Fairness and Transparency of Public Control System of Urban and Housing Redevelopment Projects", master's thesis, p.1-137, Ajoo university, 2011.
  18. chun gyu, Park, "Development Direction of the Public Management System for Urban and Housing Development Projects", master's thesis, p.1-51, hanbat university, 2011.
  19. JuHyun, Cho, "A study on the improvement of the legislative system for the housing reconstruction efficiency", master's thesis, p.1-102, konkuk university, 2010.
  20. Seung Kyoo, Kim, "A study on the system improvement of the urban and residential environment projects", master's thesis, p.1-91, konkuk university, 2010.
  21. Pil-hwan, Park, "A Study on the Problems and Improvements of Public Management System in the Urban Redevelopment Projects", master's thesis, p.1-104, Sejong university, 2010.
  22. Jin-Kun, Lee, "The Study of Vitalization Approaches for Urban Renewal Project Implementation : Focuses on Planning District Case in North of Seoul", master's thesis, p.1-85, Seoul National University of Technology, 2010.
  23. Moon do, Han, "A study on the Improvement of Public Management System in the Urban Renewal Project", p.1-115, dongeui university, 2012.
  24. Young Jong, Kim, "A study on new town development in Seoul metropolitan city : focused on securing public interests through government involvement", doctor's thesis, p.1-171, hanyang university, 2010.
  25. Sung Ki, Jun , "A Study on the Obstacle sand Vitalizations of Residential Housing Reconstruction - Centering on Kae-Po Area-, ", master's thesis, p.1-122, kyungki university, 2011.
  26. Hyung-Sic, Yoon, "The Study of Public vs Private Role for Housing Renewel Planning : The Case Study of the Urban Renwell Promotion Area in Seoul city", master's thesis, p.1-142, Seoul National University of Technology, 2009.
  27. Gi Hong, Kim, "A study on the work of CMr in the apartment reconstruction project", master's thesis, p.1-98, Yonsei University, 2002.