Vibration control in wind turbines for performance enhancement: A comparative study

  • Received : 2014.10.19
  • Accepted : 2015.11.20
  • Published : 2016.01.25


The need for a more affordable, reliable, clean and secure energy has led to explorations in non-traditional sources, particularly renewable energies. Wind is one of the cleanest energy sources that plays a significant role in augmenting sustainability. Wind turbines, as energy convertors, are usually tall and slender structures, and depending on their location (inland or offshore), they can be subject to high wind and/or strong wave loadings. These loads can cause severe vibrations with detrimental effects on energy production, structural lifecycle and initial cost. A dissipativity analysis study was carried out to know whether wind turbine towers require damping enhancement or rigidity modifications for vibration suppression. The results suggest that wind turbines are lightly damped structures and damping enhancement is a potential solution for vibration lessening. Accordingly, the paper investigates different damping enhancement techniques for vibration mitigation. The efficacy of tuned mass damper (TMD), tuned liquid column damper (TLCD), tuned sloshing damper (TSD), and viscous damper (VD) to reduce vibrations is investigated. A comparison among these devices, in terms of robustness and effectiveness, is conducted. The VD can reduce both displacement and acceleration responses of the tower, better than other types of dampers, for the same control effort, followed by TMD, TSD, and finally TLCD. Nevertheless, the use of VDs raises concerns about where they should be located in the structure, and their application may require additional design considerations.


dissipativity analysis;wind turbine;viscous dampers;vibration control;tuned mass dampers;liquid dampers;high-rise structures


  1. Chakraborty, S. and Roy, B.K. (2011), "Reliability based optimum design of tuned mass damper in seismic vibration control of structures with bounded uncertain parameters", Probabilist. Eng. Mech., 26(2), 215-221.
  2. Chang, C.C. and Qu, W.L. (1998), "Unified dynamic absorber design formulas for wind-induced vibration control of tall buildings", Struct. Des. Tall Spec. Build., 7(2), 147-166.<147::AID-TAL107>3.0.CO;2-3
  3. Chang, C.C. (1999), "Mass dampers and their optimal designs for building vibration control", Eng. Structs., 21(5), 454-463.
  4. Chen, H., Sun, Z. and Sun, L.M. (2011), "Active mass damper control for cable stayed bridge under construction: an experimental study", Struct. Eng. Mech., 38(2), 141-156.
  5. Choi, S.B., Hong, S.R., Sung, K.G. and Sohn, J.W. (2008), "Optimal control of structural vibrations using a mixed-mode magnetorheological fluid mount", Mech. Sci., 50(3), 559-568.
  6. Christenson, R.E. (2003), "Experimental verification of smart coupled building control", Proceedings of the 2003 Structures Congress, Seattle, WA, June.
  7. Colwell, S. and Basu, B. (2009), "Tuned liquid column dampers in offshore wind turbines for structural control", Eng. Struct., 31(2), 358-368.
  8. Connor, J.J. and Connor, J.J. (2003), Introduction to Structural Motion Control, Prentice Hall Pearson Edu., Incorporated, Univ. of Michigan, Michigan, USA.
  9. Debbarma, R., Chakraborty, S. and Ghosh, S.K. (2010), "Optimum design of tuned liquid column dampers under stochastic earthquake load considering uncertain bounded system parameters", Int. J. Mech. Sci., 52(10), 1385-1393.
  10. Den Hartog, J.P. (1934), Mechanical Vibrations, McGraw-Hill Book Company, The Maple Press Company, York, PA, USA.
  11. Alexander, N.A. and Schilder, F. (2009), "Exploring the performance of a nonlinear tuned mass damper", J. Sound Vib., 319(1), 445-462.
  12. Aly, A.M. (2014a), "Vibration control of high-rise buildings for wind: a robust passive and active tuned mass damper", Smart Struct. Syst., 13(3), 473-500.
  13. Aly, A.M. (2014b), "Proposed robust tuned mass damper for response mitigation in buildings exposed to multidirectional wind", Struct. Design Tall Spec. Build., 23(9), 664-691.
  14. Aly, A.M. and Christenson, R.E. (2008), "On the evaluation of the efficacy of a smart damper: a new equivalent energy-based probabilistic approach", Smart Mater. Struct., 17(4), Article ID 045008, 11pp.
  15. Aly, A.M., Zasso, A. and Resta, F. (2011), "On the dynamics of a very slender building under winds: response reduction using MR dampers with lever mechanism", Struct. Des. Tall Spec. Build., 20(5), 539-551.
  16. Arapogianni, A. and Genach, A.B. (2013), Deep Water-the Next Step for Offshore Wind Energy, European Wind Energy Association (EWEA).
  17. Attaway, S. (2013), Matlab: A Practical Introduction to Programming and Problem Solving. Butterworth-Heinemann, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
  18. Bianchi, F.D., De Battista, H. and Mantz, R.J. (2006), Wind Turbine Control Systems: Principles, Modelling and Gain Scheduling Design, Springer Science & Business Media, Germany.
  19. Bossanyi, E.A. (2003), "Individual blade pitch control for load reduction", Wind Energy, 6(2), 119-128.
  20. Dinh, V.N. and Basu, B. (2015), "Passive control of floating offshore wind turbine nacelle and spar vibrations by multiple tuned mass dampers", Struct. Control Health Monit., 22(1), 152-176.
  21. Dinh, V.N., Basu, B. and Nielsen, S.R.K. (2013), "Impact of spar-nacelle-blade coupling on the edgewise response of floating offshore wind turbines", Coupled Syst. Mech., 2(3), 215-238.
  22. Drachmann, A.G. (1961), "Heron's Windmill", Centaurus, 7, 145-151.
  23. Duenas-Osorio, L. and Basu, B. (2008), "Unavailability of wind turbines from wind induced accelerations", Eng. Struct., 30(4), 885-893.
  24. Erkus, B. and Johnson, E.A. (2011), "Dissipativity analysis of the base isolated benchmark structure with magnetorheological fluid dampers", Smart Mater. Struct., 20, Article ID 105001.
  25. Faltinsen, O.M. (1993), Sea Loads on Ships and Offshore Structures, Cambridge Univ. Press, UK.
  26. Feng, M.Q. and Mita, A. (1995), "Vibration control of tall buildings using mega sub-configuration", Eng. Mech., 121(10), 1082-1088.
  27. Gur, S., Mishra, S.K., Bhowmick, S. and Chakraborty, S. (2014), "Compliant liquid column damper modified by shape memory alloy device for seismic vibration control", Smart Mater. Struct., 23(10), ID 105009, 14pp.
  28. Hansen, M.O.L. (2008), Aerodynamics of Wind Turbines, EarthScan, UK.
  29. Hitchcock, P.A., Kwok, K.C.S., Watkins, R.D. and Samali, B. (1997), "Characteristics of liquid column vibration absorbers (LCVA)-I", Eng. Struct., 19(2), 126-134.
  30. Hitchcock, P.A., Kwok, K.C.S., Watkins, R.D. and Samali, B. (1997), "Characteristics of liquid column vibration absorbers (LCVA)-II", Eng. Struct., 19(2), 135-144.
  31. Huo, L., Shen, W., Li, H. and Zhang, Y. (2013), "Optimal Design of Liquid Dampers for Structural Vibration Control Based on GA and $H_{\infty}$ Norm", Math. Problem. Eng., Article ID 191279.
  32. Inaudi, J.A. (2000), "Performance of Variable-Damping Systems: Theoretical Analysis and Simulation", Proceedings of the3rd Int. Workshop on Struct. Control, Paris, France, July.
  33. Jonkman, J., Butterfield, S., Musial, W. and Scott, G. (2009), Definition of a 5-MW Reference Wind Turbine for Offshore System Development, National Renewable Energy Lab., Golden, Co, Technical Report, NREL/TP-500-38060, February.
  34. Kaimal, J.C., Wyngaard, J., Izumi, Y. and Cote, O.R. (1972), "Spectral characteristics of surface-layer turbulence", Q. J. Roy. Meteorol. Soc., 98(417), 563-589.
  35. Karimirad, M. and Moan, T. (2012), "A simplified method for coupled analysis of floating offshore wind turbines", Marine Struct., 27(1), 45-63.
  36. Kim, D.H., Ju, Y.K., Kim, M.H. and Kim, S.D. (2014), "Wind-induced vibration control of tall buildings using hybrid buckling-restrained braces", Struct. Des. Tall Spec. Build., 23(7), 549-562.
  37. Lackner, M.A. and Rotea, M.A. (2011), "Structural control of floating wind turbines", Mechatronics, 21(4), 704-719.
  38. Laks, J.H., Pao, L.Y. and Wright, A.D. (2009), "Control of wind turbines: Past, present, and future", Proceedings of American Control Conference, St. Louis, USA, June.
  39. Lee, S.K., Lee, H.R. and Min, K.W. (2012), "Experimental verification on nonlinear dynamic characteristic of a tuned liquid column damper subjected to various excitation amplitudes", Struct. Des. Tall Spec. Build., 21(5), 374-388.
  40. Li, H.J., Hu, S.L.J. and Jakubiak, C. (2003), "Active vibration control for offshore platform subjected to wave loading", J. Sound Vib., 263(4), 709-724.
  41. Lin, C.C., Lin, G.L. and Wang, J.F. (2010), "Protection of seismic structures using semi-active friction TMD", Earthq. Eng. Struct. D., 39(6), 635-659.
  42. Lin, C.C., Lu, L.Y., Lin, G.L. and Yang, T.W. (2010), "Vibration control of seismic structures using semi-active friction multiple tuned mass dampers", Eng. Struct., 32(10), 3404-3417.
  43. Lohrmann, D. (1995), "Von der ostlichen zur westlichen Windmuhle", Archiv fur Kulturgeschichte, 77(1), 1-32 (in German).
  44. Lu, L.T., Chiang, W.L., Tang, J.P., Liu, M.Y. and Chen, C.W. (2003), "Active control for a benchmark building under wind excitations", J. Wind Eng. Ind. Aerod., 91(4), 469-493.
  45. Mensah, A.F. and Duenas-Osorio, L. (2014), "Improved reliability of wind turbine towers with tuned liquid column dampers (TLCDs)", Struct. Saf., 47, 78-86.
  46. Metwally, H., El-Souhily, B. and Aly, A. (2006), "Reducing vibration effects on buildings due to earthquake using magneto-rheological dampers", AEJ-Alexandria Engineering J., Elsevier, 45(2), 131-140.
  47. Min, K.W., Kim, J. and Lee, H.R. (2014a), "A design procedure of two-way liquid dampers for attenuation of wind-induced responses of tall buildings", J. Wind Eng. Ind. Aerod., 129, 22-30.
  48. Min, K.W., Kim, J. and Kim, Y.W. (2014b), "Design and test of tuned liquid mass dampers for attenuation of the wind responses of a full scale building", Smart Mater. Struct., 23(4), 045020.
  49. Mishra, S.K., Gur, S. and Chakraborty, S. (2013), "An improved tuned mass damper (SMA-TMD) assisted by a shape memory alloy spring", Smart Mater. Struct., 22(9), 1-16.
  50. Murtagh, P.J., Ghosh, A., Basu, B. and Broderick, B.M. (2008), "Passive control of wind turbine vibrations including blade/tower interaction and rotationally sampled turbulence", Wind Energy, 11(4), 305-317.
  51. Musial, W., Butterfield, S. and Ram, B. (2006), "Energy from offshore wind", Proceedings of the Offshore Tech. Conference, Houston, USA, May.
  52. NOAA, (2015), National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Official website,; page visited in March.
  53. Park, K.S. and Ok, S.Y. (2015), "Optimal design of hybrid control system for new and old neighboring buildings", J. Sound Vib., 336, 16-31.
  54. Pirner, M. and Urushadze, S. (2007), "Liquid damper for suppressing horizontal and vertical motions (parametric study)", J. Wind Eng. Ind. Aerod., 95. 1329-1349.
  55. Rezaee, M. and Aly, A.M. (2015), "Vibration control in wind turbines: A comparative study", Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Wind Engineering-ICWE14, in Porto Alegre, Brazil, June 21-26.
  56. Ronold, K.O. and Larsen, G.C. (2000), "Reliability-based design of wind-turbine rotor blades against failure in ultimate loading", Eng. Struct., 22(6), 565-574.
  57. Sakai, F., Takaeda, S. and Tamaki, T. (1989), "Tuned liquid column damper-new type device for suppression of building vibrations", Proceedings of the International Conference on High-rise Buildings, Nanjing, China, March.
  58. Sarpkaya, T. and Isaacson, M. (1981), Mechanics of Wave Forces on Offshore Structures, Reihhold van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York, USA.
  59. Sebastian, T. and Lackner, M.A. (2012), "Development of a free vortex wake method code for offshore floating wind turbines", Renew. Energ., 46, 269-275.
  60. Si, Y., Karimi, H.R. and Gao, H. (2014), "Modelling and optimization of a passive structural control design for a spar-type floating wind turbine", Eng. Struct., 69, 168-182.
  61. Simiu, E. and Scanlan, R. (1996), Wind Effects on Structures, John Wiley & Sons, New York, USA.
  62. Smith, R.J. and Willford, M.R. (2007), "The damped outrigger concept for tall buildings", Struct. Des. Tall Spec. Build., 16(4), 501-517.
  63. Soong, T.T. and Chen, W.F. (1990), Active Structural Control: Theory and Practice, Longman Scientific & Technical, New York, USA.
  64. Stewart, G.M. and Lackner, M.A. (2014), "The impact of passive tuned mass dampers and wind-wave misalignment on offshore wind turbine loads", Eng. Struct., 73, 54-61.
  65. Veers, P.S., Ashwill, T.D., Sutherland, H.J., Laird, D.L., Lobitz, D.W., Griffin, D.A. and Richmond, J.L. (2003), "Trends in the design, manufacture and evaluation of wind turbine blades", Wind Energy, 6(3), 245-259.
  66. Wayman, E.N., Sclavounos, P.D., Butterfield, S., Jonkman, J. and Musial, W. (2006), "Coupled dynamic modeling of floating wind turbine systems", Proceedings of the Offshore Tech. Conference, Houston, USA, May.
  67. Weber, F. (2014), "Semi-active vibration absorber based on real-time controlled MR damper", Mech. Syst. Signal Pr., 46(2-3), 272-288.
  68. Weber, F. and Maslanka, M. (2012), "Frequency and damping adaptation of a TMD with controlled MR damper", Smart Mater. Struct., 21(5), 055011.
  69. WWEA, (2015), World Wind Energy Association,; page visited in March.
  70. Wu, J.C. and Pan, B.C. (2002), "Wind tunnel verification of actively controlled high-rise building in along-wind motion", J. Wind Eng. Ind. Aerod., 90(12-15), 1933-1950.

Cited by

  1. On the evaluation of wind loads for wind turbines' foundation design: Experimental and numerical investigations vol.26, pp.9, 2017,
  2. Modeling and mitigation of excessive dynamic responses of wind turbines founded in warm permafrost vol.148, 2017,
  3. Investigation of the Performance of Two Passive Controllers in Mitigating the Rotational Response of Irregular Buildings vol.2016, 2016,
  4. Vibration control in wind turbines to achieve desired system-level performance under single and multiple hazard loadings pp.15452255, 2018,


Supported by : National Science Foundation (NSF)