Korean Management Science Review (경영과학)

The Korean Operations Research and Management Science Society (한국경영과학회)
권호 표지

Performance Evaluation of the Research-Funding Agencies: Focused on the Evaluation Items of KOSEF

연구지원기관의 성과평가에 관한 연구: 한국과학재단에 대한 평가항목을 중심으로

  • Published : 1997.05.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study concerns performance evaluation of the research-funding agencies focused on Korea Science and Engineering Foundation(KOSEF). On the basis of the constituents approach and the systems approach of organizational effectiveness theory, the evaluation items are derived reflecting generic characteristics of the research-funding agencies, and their priorities are determined using analytic hierarchy process(AHP). Three groups of constituents with differing interest and expections are identified, and their perceptions on the importance of the evaluation items are measured through questionnaire survey. Analyses show that the evaluation items perceived important by each constituency are significant different from one another. The implications of the result to the Government and KOSEF are discussed.

Keywords

References

  1. 과학기술정책동향 no.64 '93 출연(연) 기관평가 사례 분석 민철구;조황희;이정원;이영한
  2. '93 출연(연) 기관평가 모델개발 연구 민철구;조황희;이정원;이영한
  3. 1995년도 자체평가보고서 한국과학재단
  4. California Management Review v.32 no.3 The Chief Technology Officer Alder,P.S.;K.Ferdows
  5. The Evaluation of Scientific Research, Ciba Foundation Conference The Evaluation of Research Training Anderson,J.
  6. Administrative Science Quarterly v.23 no.4 Measuring Organizational Effectiveness in Institution of Higher Eduction Cameron,K.S.
  7. Management Science v.32 no.5 Effectiveness as Paradox: Consensus and Confict in Conceptions of Organizational Effectiveness Cameron,K.S.
  8. Academy of Management Review v.5 no.2 Organizational Effectiveness: A Multiple-Constituency Approach Connolly,T.;E.J.Conlon;S.J.Deutsch
  9. Evaluation Review v.18 no.1 Grants Peer Review in Theory and Practice Chubin,D.E.
  10. Organization Theory and Design(2nd Ed.) Daft,R.L.
  11. Research Policy v.19 no.5 Quantification of the Performance of Research Units: A Simple Mathematical Model Englisch,H.;H.J.Czerwon
  12. Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach Freeman,R.E.
  13. Technological Forecasting and Social Change v.47 no.2 Key Output Indicators in Performance Evaluation of Research and Development Organizations Geisler,E.
  14. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management v.16 no.1 An Evaluation of Measurable Characteristics Within Army Laboratories Harrold,R.W.
  15. Academy of Management Journal v.22 A Methodology to Develop the Criteria Weightings for Assessing Subunit Effectiveness in Organization Hitt,M.A.;R.D.Middlemist
  16. Science, Technology and Human Values v.10 no.3 Peer Review in the Regulatory Process Jasanoff,S.
  17. Academy of Mangement Journal v.25 no.1 Constituent Views of Organizational Effectiveness: Evidence from Police Organizations Jobson,J.D.;R.Schneck
  18. The Social Psycology of Organization The Concept of organizational Effectiveness Katz,D.;R.L.Kahn;Katz,D.(ed.);Kahn,R.L.(ed.)
  19. Administrative Science Quarterly v.12 Differentiation and Integration in Complex Organization Lawrence,P.R.;J.W.Lorsch
  20. Management Science v.32 no.5 Determining Organizational Effectiveness: Another Lock and an Agenda for Research Lewin,A.Y.;J.W.Minton
  21. Sloan Management Review v.21 no.2 Enterpreneurs, Champions and Technologyical Innovation Maidique,M.A.
  22. Academy of Management Journal v.35 no.3 Distributive and Procedural Justice as Predictors of Satisfaction with Personal and Organizational Outcomes McFarlin,D.B.;P.D.Sweeney
  23. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management v.38 no.3 The Prioritization of Technologies in Research Laboratory Melachrinoudis,E.;K.Rice
  24. Research Policy v.13 no.4 Recent Results in Measuring Innovation Output Meyer-Krahmer,F.
  25. Research Policy v.18 no.6 Evaluations of Innovation Programmes in Selected European Countries Meyer-Krahmer,F.;P.Montigny
  26. Employee-Organization Linkages: Absenteeism, and Turnover Mowday,R.T.;L.M.Porter;R.M.Steers
  27. Human Relations v.26 Task Environment, Decentralization and Organizational Effectiveness Negandhi,A.R.;B.C.Reimann
  28. General Distribution Evaluation of Programmes Promoting Technological Innovation OECD
  29. External Control of Organization Pfeffer,J.;G.R.Salancik
  30. New Perspectives on Organizational Effectiveness Toward a Workable Framework Pennings,J.M.;P.S.Goodman;Goodman,P.S.(ed.);J.M.Pennings(ed.)
  31. Organizational Theory: Structure, Design, and Application(3rd Ed.) Robbins,S.P.
  32. Research Policy v.18 no.6 Evaluation of Government Innovation Programs: Introduction Roessner,J.D.
  33. Research Policy v.18 no.6 Evaluating Government Innovation Programs: Lessons from the U.S. Experience Roessner,J.D.
  34. Evaluation: A Systematic Approach(4th Ed) Rossi,P.H.;H.E.Freeman
  35. Journal of Mathematical Psychology v.15 no.3 A Scaling Method for Priorities in Hierarchical Structures Saaty,T.L.
  36. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management v.30 no.3 Priority Setting in Complex Problem Saaty,T.L.
  37. New Perspective on Organizational Effectiveness Effectiveness of Organizational Effectiveness Studies Scott,W.R.;Goodman,P.S.(ed.);J.M.Pennings(ed.)
  38. Administrative Science Quarterly v.20 no.4 Problems in the Measurement of Organizational Effectiveness Steers,R.M.
  39. Administrative Science Quarterly v.30 no.3 A Multiple-Constituency Model of Effectiveness: An Empirical Examination at the Human Resource Subunit Level Tsui,A.S.
  40. Administrative Science Quarterly v.23 no.2 Coping with Incompatible Expectations: An Integrated View of Role Conflict Whetten,D.A.