Journal of Nutrition and Health

The Korean Nutrition Society (한국영양학회)
권호 표지

Sources of Variability of Multiple Self-reported 24-hour Recalls in Dietary Survey

식이조사방법중 자기 기록식 24시간 회상 반복 조사의 변이원에 관한 연구

  • 김연희 (한양대학교 생활과학대학 식품영양학과)
  • Published : 1997.04.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study was designed to study sources of variability(subjects, day by day, season, day of week, sequence, number of repeated days, compliance etc.) in multiple 24-hour dietary recall method. Dietary intakes of college women in Seoul were obtained using 24-hour dietary recalls, consecutive 7 days, 4 times for 1 year. The result of this study shows that 1) the reproducibility of multiple 24-hour recalls is low(intraclass correlation coefficient<0.3), 2) the intraindividual variations of all nutrients are more than 80%, 3) the major components of variation are interindividual vriability and intraindividual variability(within person variability and methodologic error). There were small but statistically significant season and compliance effects. 4) the ratio within-person varation to between-person variation for absolute and transformed nutrient intakes except some nutrients such as vitamin A, vitamin C, energy from protein and fat etc, was less than 1.7 the minimum numbers of days needed in 24-hour dietary recalls to estimate usual intake for this group were 1 to 21 days. And the numbers of days needed to get the usual intake of an individual varied among individuals and within individuals for different nutrients, ranged from 1 days for log carbohydrate(% energy) to 470 days for Na. 6) There were greater than 0.7 correlation coefficients between the average nutrient intakes of 12 days and intakes of 28 days. Therefore, it was desirable to take the 24-hour recall more than 12 times, repeating 3 days every season.

Keywords

References

  1. Am J Clin Nutr v.32 Sources of variance in 24-hour dietary recall data : implications for nutrition study design and interpretation Beaton,G.H.;Milner,J.;Corey,P.;McGuire,V.;Cousins,M.;Stewart,E.;Ramos,M.;Hewitt,D.;Grambsch,P.V.
  2. Am J Clin Nutr v.37 Sources of variance in 24-hour dietary recall data : implications for nutrition study design and interpretation-Carbohydrates sources, vitamins, and minerals Beaton,G.H.;Milner,J.;Corey,P.;McGuire,V.;Feather,T.E.;Alick,J.L.
  3. Am J Clin Nutr v.50 Between-and within-subject variation in nutrient intake from infancy to old age : estimation the number of day required to rank dietary intakes with desired precision Nelson,M.;Black,A.E.;Morris,J.A.;Cole,T.J.
  4. Am J Clin Nutr v.37 Food intake measurement : problems and approaches Todd,K.S.;Hudes,M.;Coolway,D.H.
  5. Am J Epidemiol v.121 Effects of intraindividual and interindividual variation in repeated dietary records Sempos,C.T.;Johnson,N.E.;Smith,E.L.;Gilligan,C.
  6. Am J Clin Nutr v.54 The nature and individuality of within subjects variation in energy intake Tarasuk,V.;Beaton,G.H.
  7. Am J Clin Nutr v.50 Sources of variation in energy intake by men and women as determined from one year's daily dietary records Basiotis,P.P.;Thomas,R.G.;Kelsay,J.L.;Mertx,W.
  8. 국민균형식 모형개발을 위한 연구 한국식품공업협회 한국식품연구소
  9. 식품섭취 실태조사를 위한 식품 및 음식의 눈대중량 한국식품공업협회 한국식품연구소
  10. 식품섭취 조사방법 확립을 위한 연구-실측치와 회상치의 비교- 한국식품공업협회 식품연구소
  11. J Chron Dis v.36 Dietary variability and its impact on nutritional epidemiology Lozy,M.
  12. 좋은 식단실시 방안에 관한 연구 한국식품공업협회 한국식품연구소
  13. 좋은 식단 정착을 위한 조리법 표준화에 관한 연구 한국식품공업협회 한국식품연구소
  14. 한국인영양권장량-제 6차 개정판 한국영양학회
  15. Nutritional epidemiology Willett,W.C.
  16. J Am Diet Assoc v.71 Adaption of the 24-hour recall for epidemiologic studies of school children Frank,G.C.;Berenson,G.S.;Schilling,P.E.;Moore,M.C.
  17. J Nutr v.117 Number of days of food intake records required to estimate individual and group nutrient intakes with defined confidence Basiotis,P.P.;Welsh,S.O.;Cronin,F.J.;Kelsay,J.L.;Mertx,W.
  18. 한국영양학회지 v.26 no.3 여대생의 영양섭취 상태 및 혈액성상에 관한 연구 홍순영;백금주;정선희;오경원;홍영애
  19. 한국영양학회지 v.11 no.4 일부 도시지역 여대생의 영양성 빈혈에 관한 연구 임현숙
  20. 한국영양학회지 v.24 no.6 대학생의 식이 섬유 섭취에 관한 연구 이혜성;이연경;Chen,S.C.
  21. 한국영양학회지 v.25 no.2 7일 실측법에 의한 영양소섭취량의 개인간 변이와 개인내 변이 정해랑;문현경;송범호;김미경
  22. 지역사회영양학회지 v.1 no.3 자기기록식 반정량 식이 섭취 빈도조사의 신뢰도 및 타당도 연구-서울지역 중년 남성을 대상으로- 김미경;이상선;안윤옥
  23. J Am Diet Assoc v.62 Accuracy of 24-hour recalls in young children Emmons,W.;Hayes,M.
  24. Eur J Clin Nut v.48 The relative validity of the repeated 24-hour recall for estimation energy and selected nutrient intakes of rural Ganaian-children Ferguson,E.l.;Gibson,R.S.;Opare-Obisaw,C.
  25. Assessing Changing Food Consumption Patterns Can nutrition status be determined from consumption or other measures? Schaefer,A.E.
  26. Int J Obes v.10 Seasonal variation in food intake, pattern of physical activity and change in body weight in a group of young adult Dutch women consuming self-selected diets Van Staveren,W.A.;Duerenberg,P.;Burema,J.;deGroot,L.C.;Hautvast,J.G.
  27. Am J Clin Nutr v.45 Seasonal variation in intake of carotenoids and vegetables and fruits among white men in New Jersey Zeigler,R.G.;Wilcox,H.B.;Mason,T.H.;Bill,J.S.;Virgo,P.W.
  28. Am J Clin Nutr v.36 Within-person variability of nutrient intake in a group of Hawaiian men of Japanese ancestry McGee,D.;Rhoads,G.;Hankin,J.;Yano,K.;Tillotson,J.
  29. Nutr Abstr Rev v.57 The dietary assessment of individuals : methods, accuracy, new techniques and recommendations Bingham,S.A.
  30. J Am Diet Assoc v.90 The apparent validity of diet questionnaires is influenced by number of diet-record days used for comparison Potosky,A.L.;Block,G.;Hartman,A.M.