A Comparative Study of Relationships among Energy Intakes, Energy Expenditure, Physical Activity and Cardiovascular Disease Related Factors in Vegetarians and Non-Vegetarians

채식인과 비채식인의 섭취열량, 소비열량 및 활동량과 심혈관질환 관련인자와의 관련성에 관한 비교연구

  • 차복경 (한서대학교 자연요양복지학과)
  • Published : 2001.04.01

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to verify the relation among vegetarian diet, physical activity and the risk factors of cardiovascular disease. Two hundred and forty five buddhist nuns (age : 23~79 yrs) were selected as vegetarians. For control subjects, 235 healthy female adults (age : 23~79 yrs) were selected. Study period was from October 1996 to February 1997. The contents are consist of food consumption survey, anthropometric measurement, amount of energy expenditure, physical activity and clinical examination. Results were summarized as follows : The average ages of vegetarians were $44.2{\pm}17.3\;yrs$ and those of non-vegetarians were $40.5{\pm}18.4\;yrs$. Average body mass indices (BMI) of vegetarians and non-vegetarians were $22.5{\pm}2.7\;and\;21.1{\pm}2.5$, WHRs were $0.9{\pm}0.1\;and\;0.8{\pm}0.1$, and the average duration of vegetarian diet of the vegetarians was 13.1{\pm}12.9 years. All the nutrient intakes of both groups were over RDA's except calcium and vitamin A intakes of non-vegetarians that were below RDA's Fiber and vitamin C intakes of the vegetarians were significantly higher than those of non-vegetarians (p<0.01). Average energy intakes of vegetarians and non-vegetarians were $2177.1{\pm}420.6\;kcal/day\;and\;2103.2{\pm}534.9\;kcal/day$, total daily energy expenditure were $1789.9{\pm}325.8\;kcal/day\;and\;1703.8{\pm}344.8\;kcal/day$, those by physical activity were $507.8{\pm}360.9\;kcal/day\;and\;400.0{\pm}247.8\;kcal/day$. Serum lipid level, blood sugar, systolic blood pressure of vegetarians were significantly lower than those of non-vegetarians, but ratio of HDL-cholesterol/total-cholesterol was higher than those of non-vegetarians. Levels of total serum cholesterol of vegetarians and non-vegetarians were 161.4{\pm}33.3 mg/dL and 189.6{\pm}33.6mg/dL, HDL-cholesterol were $48.2{\pm}11.4\;mg/dL\;and\;50.8{\pm}12.2\;mg/dL$, LDL-cholesterol were $86.6{\pm}26.9\;mg/dL\;and\;111.1{\pm}17.0\;mg/dL$, atherogenic indice(AI) were $2.4{\pm}0.6\;and\;2.9{\pm}0.7$, fasting blood sugar were $90.8{\pm}14.3\;mg/dL\;and\;103.6{\pm}24.6\;mg/dL$, systolic blood pressure were $107.5{\pm}14.9\;mmHg\;and\;119.3{\pm}15.3\;mmHg$. Energy expenditure by physical activity was negatively correlated with levels of serum total-cholesterol and LDL-cholesterol and atherogenic indice(AI). Therefore, physical activity and vegetarian diet effectively helped reduce blood lipids related to cardiovascular disease.

우리나라에도 심혈관질환으로 인한 사망률이 점차 증가하고 있다. 이에 본 연구에서는 채식과 심혈관질환과의 관계를 규명하기 위한 연구의 일환으로 채식을 하는 비구니스님을 대상으로 하여 연구한 결과를 요약하면 다음과 같다. 조사 대상자의 평균나이는 채식인 44.20세, 비채식인 40.52세, BMI는 각각 22.47, 21.08이었고, WHR은 0.85, 0.84였고, %BF는 28.79, 26.55였으며, 채식인의 평균채식기간은 13.16년이었다. 조사 대상자의 영양소 섭취실태는 채식인은 모든 영양소가 권장량을 상회하였고, 비채식인은 Ca, 비타민 A가 권장량을 미달하였다. 섬유소와 비타민 C 섭취량은 채식인이 유의적으로(p<0.01) 높았다. 조사 대상자의 소비에너지는 채식군 1789.84 kcal, 비채식군 1703.83 kcal로 채식군이 유의하게 많았고(p<0.05), 활동량도 채식군 507.76 kcal, 비채식군 400.03 kcal로 채식군이 유의하게 높았다(p<0.01). 조사 대상자의 total cholesterol, LDL-cholesterol, AI, 이완기혈압 및 혈당은 비채식인이 유의적으로(p<0.01) 높았고, HDL-cholesterol은 (p<0.05) 비채식인이 유의적으로 높았으며 심질환 예견지수인 HDL/total cholesterol 비는 채식인이 유의적으로(p<0.01) 높았다. 활동량은 두군 모두 중성지방, 혈청 총 콜레스테롤, LDL-cholesterol, AI와는 역상관을 보였다(p<0.05). 이상의 결과에서 채식군은 비채식군에 비해 혈중지질 수준, 혈당, 혈압에 영향을 미치는 것으로 알려진 BMI, RBW, WHR,%BF가 유의적으로 높았음(p<0.05)에도 불구하고 혈정 총콜레스테롤, LDL-choleserol, AI 및 수축기혈압이 유의적으로 낮았는데 이는 여러가지 요인이 있겠지만 채식군이 비채식군에 비해 섬유소, 비타민 C의 섭취량 및 활동량이 유의하게(p<0.01) 높았기 때문으로 생각된다. 따라서 혈중지질 수준, 혈당, 혈압에 영향을 미치는 것은 식이요인 뿐만 아니라 활동량 등 여러가지 생활양식이 영향을 미치는 것으로 볼 수 있다.

Keywords

References

  1. Yearbook of health and social statistics Ministry of health and welfare
  2. 97' National nutrition survey report Ministry of health and welfare
  3. Int.J.Epidemiol. v.18 no.Suppl.1 Trends in CHD in the Unites States Huggins,M;Thom,T
  4. J.Am.Diet.Assoc. v.62 The vegetarian diet Register,U.D;Sonnenbang,L.M
  5. Am.J.Nutr. v.36 Vegetarianism,dietary fiber and mortality Burt,M.L;Sweetnam,P.M
  6. 第 38回 日本榮養改善學會 中年女性の血中脂質水準に 及ばす 食生活と 運動習慣の影響 伊藤晶子
  7. Jpn.J.Nutr. v.48 Public health nutrition activity and behavioral science Takeo,N;Takashi,Y;Tsuchida,M;Heizo,T
  8. Am.J.Clin Nutr v.31 Dietary fiber,plasma insulin, and obesity Albrink,M.J
  9. Circulation v.28 Coronary heart disease among Minnesota business and professional men followed 15years Keys,A;Taylor,H.L;Blacburn,H
  10. West J.Med. v.140 Seventh-day abventist adolescents-lifestyle patterns and cardiovascular disease risk factors Cooper,R;Allen,A;Goldberg,R;Trevisan,M;Van Horn,L;Liu,K;Steinhaur,M;Rubenstein,A;Stamler,J
  11. Am J.Clin Nutr. v.34 Nutrient intake and health status of vegaris Abdulla,M.D;Ingrid,A;NIls-Georg Asp,M.D;Knud Berthlsen,M.D;Dowen Birkhed,D.D.S;Ingrid,D.K
  12. Engl.J.Med. v.292 Plasmal lipids and lipoproteins in vegetanans and controls Sacks,F.M;Castelli,W.P;Donner,A;Kass,E.H
  13. J.Nutr. v.119 Antioxidant action of carotenoids Burton,G.W
  14. Food Technology in Australia v.33 no.Feb Coles-Rutishauser and Littlejohn.G.O: The role of dietary fibre in human health Wahlqvist,G.P;Jones,J;Hansky,S.D;Duncan,I
  15. Am.J.Clin.Nutr. v.59 no.Suppl Vegetarian and other complex diets,fats,fiber, and hypertension Lawrence,J.B
  16. Biochem.Biophys.Acta v.27 Antioxidant and coantioxidant activity of vitamin C,vitamin E or water-soluble vitamin E analogue upon the peroxidation of aqueous multillamella phospholipid liposomes Doba,T;Burton,G;Ingold,K.U
  17. Lipids v.24 Ascorbic acid glutathione and synthetic antioxidants prevents the oxidation of vitamin E in platelets Yatassery,G.T;Smith,W.E;Quach,H.T
  18. 식이요법 모수미
  19. Int.J.Obes. v.13 A validation study of body fat distribution as determined by self-measurement of waist and hip circumference Hall,T.R;Young,T.B
  20. Nutrition and intergrated approach(3rd ed) Ruth,L.P
  21. The Korean Nutrition Society (Matab data system) The Korean Nutrition Society
  22. Am.J.Clin Nutr. v.37 A method to assess energy expenditure in children and adults Bouvhard,C;Tremblay,A;Ledlanc,C;Lortise,G;Savard,R;Theriault,G
  23. J.Korean Soc Food Nutr. v.22 A study on daily energy expenditure of co-eds in a university Kim,S.Y
  24. Clin.Chem. v.36 Triglyceride measurements, a review of methods and interferences Kkitzsch,S.G;McNamara,J.R
  25. Clin Chem. v.18 Lipid Friedwald,W.T
  26. Recommended dietary allowance for Koreans(6th revision) The Korean nutrition society
  27. Yearbook of health and wellbeing statistics Ministry of health and welfare
  28. Korean J.Nutr. v.15 A Nutritional servey of buddhist nuns Yoon,J.S;Lee,W.J
  29. Relationships among body fat distribution, fasting serum insulin, eating behaviour,and energy intake in adult female Kim,S.Y
  30. Approach to nutritional status for uncooked food vegetarian, vegetarian, non-vegetarian and evaluation of uncooked powered foods Yoon,O.H
  31. J.Am.Diet Ass v.72 Nutritional status of lacto-ovo-vegetarian(Trappist monks) Ken Resnicow,P.D;Jeanine Barone,M.S;Barbara,F;Michael,P.T
  32. The Korean J Int.Med. v.47 The levels of serum lipid in healthy Korean adults Shin,Y.G;Bae,S.G
  33. Hypertension v.6 Lack of on effect of dietary saturated fat and cholesterol on blood pressure in normotensives Sacks,F.M;Marais,G.E;Handysides,G
  34. J.Human Nutr. v.35 Plasma cholesterol and blood pressure in vogetarians Burr,M.L;Bates,A.M;Fehily,A.S
  35. A comparative study on CHD risk factors among vegetarians and non-vegetarians Kim,J.S
  36. The effects of weight-training on body composition,plasma lipids and bon density in premenopausal and promenopausal women Park,H.C