Practical Evaluation of Intellectual Capital (IC) Measurement Tool for Contract Foodservice Management Company

위탁급식전문업체 지적자본 측정도구의 운용시험 평가

  • Park, Moon-Kyunkg (Research institute of Food and Nutritional Science, Yonsei University) ;
  • Yang, Il-Sun (Department of Food & Nutrition, Yonsei University)
  • 박문경 (연세대학교 식품영양과학연구소) ;
  • 양일선 (연세대학교 식품영양학과)
  • Published : 2005.12.01

Abstract

The purposes of this study were to a) measure the IC identified of CFMC (contract foodservice management company) ,b) examine IC circumstance of CFMC, c) evaluate practically IC measurement tool of CFMC, and d) present information for selecting an adequate CFMC to clients. The questionnaires of IC measurement were handed out to 108 CFMCs, there composing of main office employees, foodservice managers, customers, and clients of 207 school,38 hospital, and 86 husiness/industry foodservices. The statistical data analysis was completed using SPSS Win (ver 12.0) for descriptive analysis, t-test, Mann-Whitney U test. First, CFMCs had operational experience for an average of 8 years and 8 months, and served an average of 38,540 meals a day. Most of the respondent companies specialized in the school foodservice field and managed an average of 66 clients for the contract period of 2 years and 3 months. Second, the respondent companies had gotten a score of 77.78 points for the total average, 77.7 points in the large enterprise group and 78.1 points in the small and medium-sized enterprise group. Therefore, the minimum number of points for the accrediting license on Qualification is suggested to be over 70 out of a 100 point scale; this study would be serve as reference for the certification license on qualification. On the level of evaluation category, the scores were 14.15 to 20 points on $\ulcorner$finance$\urcorner$, 19.24 to 25 points on $\ulcorner$customer$\urcorner$, 19.33 to 25 points on $\ulcorner$process$\urcorner$, 14.31 to 20 points on $\ulcorner$human resource$\urcorner$, and 8.6 to 10 point on $\ulcorner$renewal and development$\urcorner$ . $\ulcorner$Renewal and development$\urcorner$ and $\ulcorner$customer focus$\urcorner$ received better grades than other evaluation categories. Third, $\ulcorner$Finance$\urcorner$ indicated similar distribution overall. Small and medium-sized companies had lower grades than large companies on 'market ability' of $\ulcorner$customer$\urcorner$ , but, clients of small and medium-sized companies had higher grade for 'client satisfaction' than large companies. Most of the companies supported 'infrastructure support for foodservice operation' of $\ulcorner$process$\urcorner$ by the main office of CFMCs, but, the branch chain offices of CFMCs were not applied efficiently. Large companies made more effort to improve the 'employee ability' of $\ulcorner$human focus$\urcorner$ than small and medium-sized CFMC. The 'research and development cost' of $\ulcorner$renewal and development$\urcorner$ was increased compared to the previous year. In conclusion, if CFMCs were to perform self-evaluation and a routine checkups by utilizing CFMC's IC measuring tool, improvements in CFMC operational capacities as well as foodservice quality can be noted. (Korean J Nutrition 38(10)'880$\sim$894,2005)

Keywords

References

  1. Choi SC. Study on foodservice company's profit management through the diverse types of foodservice contract. Korean J Hospitality Administration 10(3): 275-301, 2001
  2. Korea Food Information Institute. Present and future of contract foodservice. Food World 2(5): 28-38, 2004
  3. Eum YR, Ryu ES. Anlysis of currenet operational practices and issues of contract-managed foodservice companies in Republic of Korea. J Korean Ditetic Assoc 9(3): 197-208, 2003
  4. Park JY. Sales strategy planning through analyzing the factors affecting the foodservice management contract. Yonsei university, graduate school of human environmental sciences MD thesis, 2003
  5. Lee CS. Determinants of long-term orientation in foodservice contractor-client relationships Kyonggi university MD thesis, 2002
  6. Song JY. Development of measurements based on Balanced Score Card (BSC) for the purpose of evaluating performance of school foodservice operations. Yonsei university MD thesis, 2003
  7. Hyun SW. Developing meal pricing and capital investment guideline in contract-managed high school foodservice. Yonsei university MD thesis, 2002
  8. Lee SJ. The development of quality management standards and tool for the quality improvement of hospital food and nutrition services. Yonsei university Ph.D. thesis, 1999
  9. Kim JS. The analysis of the management of contracted hospital food services and perspectives of each party involved. Yonsei university, graduate school of human environmental sciences MD thesis, 2002
  10. Kim JH. Inter group analysis of importance and performance of foodservice tasks and conflicts to improve satisfaction index between dietitians from hospitals and contract managed foodservice companies. Yonsei university, graduate school of human environmental sciences MD thesis, 2004
  11. Park SY. Strategic planning for the contract-managed hospital foodservice through QFD methodology. Yonsei university MD thesis, 2003
  12. Yang IS. Deveopment of evaluation tool for efficient foodservice system and operation in Yonsei university. Yonsei university coop research report, 1995
  13. Yang IS. Operation evaluation and developmental strategy for efficient foodservice management of Yonsei university foodservice. Yonsei university coop research report, 1996
  14. Yang IS. Development and application of total quality service evaluation tool for contract foodservice management companies's business strategic plan. LG distribution co. FS part research report, 1999
  15. Yang IS, Park MK, Lee HY. An inquiring demand for certification of contract foodservice management company by in-depth interview and a review about the system in a related field. J Korean Dietetic Assoc 10(2) : 218-223, 2004
  16. Yang IS, Park MK, Cha JA, Lee KT, Park SY. Identification of foodservice operation evaluation model's criteria items for certifying contract foodservice management company. Korean J Food Cookery Sci 20(3): 247-255, 2004
  17. Park MK, Yang IS. Development of intellectual capital measurement tool of contract foodservice management company. the 1st international foodservice management and culinary symposium (IFMCS) proceeding: Globalization of foodservice industry. 13-14: 254-283, 2004
  18. Brotherton B. The Handbook of Contemporary Hospitality Management Research. John Wiley & Sons, 1999
  19. Schwab D. Research Methods for Organizational Studies. Mahwah NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc., 1999
  20. Lee HY. The impact of organizational culture on total quality management strategy in family restaurants. Yonsei university Ph.D. thesis, 2002
  21. Korea accounting institute http://www.kasb.or.kr
  22. Ministry of commerce, industry and energy: www.mocie.go.kr
  23. The national assembly of the republic of Korea: www.assembly.go.kr
  24. Informatization promotion committee: www.ipc.go.kr
  25. Fair trade commission: www.ftc.go.kr