Noise Source Identification of a Starter Motor using DOE (Design of Experiments: A Case Study)

실험계획법을 이용한 차량용 시동장치의 소음원 규명 및 개선 사례에 관한 연구

  • Park, Soon-Sik (Department of R&D, Valeo Electrical Systems Korea Ltd.) ;
  • Lim, Byoung-Duk (Department of Mechanical Engineering, Yeungnam University)
  • 박순식 (발레오전장시스템스코리아㈜) ;
  • 임병덕 (영남대학교 기계공학과)
  • Published : 2008.02.01

Abstract

The starter motor noise is usually well identified by the customers since it is operated while the engine is quiet, and leaves distinct impressions of the vehicle. In this study the design of experiments(DOE) was applied to the identification of the noise sources of direct drive starter motor since this process usually requires lengthy analysis and elaborate experiments. In the first stage of the test, five controllable factors(alignment and dynamic unbalance of armature, tightening torques of T/bolt and center bracket bolt, and alignment of the center bracket-yoke-rear bracket), excluding static unbalance, are sorted out of all possible factors. Test results showed that the dynamic unbalance and misalignment of armature are the major factors. However, the error level of the first test was relatively high, indicating that there might be some missing major factors. In the second stage test the results showed that both static and dynamic unbalances are the dominant factors contributing to more than 80% of the overall noise, while the misalignment contributes around 12%. Error of the second test was about 4% that could be considered satisfactory. The noise level of the optimal product was predicted to be reduced by 19dBA, and verification test showed the average noise reduction of 16.8dBA with the standard deviation of 3.2dBA, and proved the usefulness of the whole DOE process.

Keywords

References

  1. B.-H. Kim, S. Hong and J. Song, "A Study of Turbocharger Noise for Passenger Powertrains," Fall Conference Proceedings, Vol.III, KSAE, pp.1707-1712, 2006
  2. T. S. Gang, "Vehicle Noise Experiment accor ding Impeller Type of Fuel Pump," Fall Conference Proceedings, Vol.III, KSAE, pp.1773- 1778, 2006
  3. S. Y. Jeong, K. H. Kim and M. H. Park, "Analysis of Flow Field and Noise for an Automobile Cooling Fan," Spring Conference Proceedings, Vol.III, KSAE, pp.1379-1384, 2002
  4. S. J. Suh, J. Chung, B. D. Lim and C. H. Hwang, "Noise Source Identification of an Automobile Alternator by RPM Dependent Noise and Vibration Spectrum Analysis," Noise Control Engi-neering Journal, Vol.37, pp.31-36, 1992
  5. Y. Y. Sun, J. H. Kim et al., "Noise Performance Optimization of Fanblock in a Notebook Computer using the Design of Experiments," Proceeding of the 2007 Spring Conference of the Korean Society for Noise and Vibration Engineering, 2007
  6. M. G. Han and C. K. Park, "Optimization for Reduction of Squeal Noise in Caliper Brake System Using Taguchi Method," Fall Conference Proceedings, KSAE, pp.480-485, 2000
  7. S.-H. Lee, MINITAB, Measurement System Analysis, Ine. Tech., Korea, 2002