The Comparison of Residents' Movement and Activities of Public Rental Apartments in Korea and the United States - Focused on the Comparison of SH Apartments and PHA Apartments -

한국과 미국 공공 임대아파트 거주자의 이동과 단지 내 활동 - 서울 SH공사 아파트와 미네소타 주 PHA 아파트의 비교를 중심으로 -

  • 신경주 (한양대학교 실내환경디자인학과) ;
  • 장상옥 (경상대학교 가정교육과)
  • Published : 2008.04.25

Abstract

The purpose of this research is to compare residents' movement and activities in SH apartment in Yangcheon-Gu, Seoul (SH apartment) and PHA apartment in St. Paul, Minnesota (PHA apartment) in order to improve the quality of rental housing environment. This study had surveyed 418 residents of SH apartments in Korea and used the secondary data gathered from 1,462 residents of PHA apartments in the United States. The results of this study are as follows: The criteria of Korean residents in SH apartments when choosing their residences are lower rent payment and shorter waiting time. They seemed to have no other options than public rental housing. On the contrary, American residents in PHA apartment had more option to choose from. Therefore, Korea needs to offer more variety types of residents that can be lead to better satisfaction of low income classes. Most of the SH apartments residents has lived for long-term, in the average of more than 6 years, and wanted to live continually at their current dwelling. PHA residents showed similar tendency. However, long term residency may lead to permanent occupation of the public rental apartment by the same family. Hence, a system which can provide equal residency opportunities to all low-income classes need to be developed. Residents of SH apartment were satisfied with the personal activities but were not satisfied with group activities among residents or regarding resident meetings. However, residents of PHA apartments were more satisfied with their management because there is more in-housing-complex activity programs. Therefore, more activity program for a resident should be developed after analysing programs of different apartments and current conditions in Korea. There were some noticeable divergences among residents, based on their age, term of residence and physical, emotional and mental problem, when evaluating in-housing-complex's programs. Thus, these factors are also need to be considered when planning and examining evaluation about the management of rental apartments.

Keywords

References

  1. 김선웅(2006), 미국의 저소득층을 위한 주거정책 현황 개괄: 정부간의 역할 분담과 정책 사례를 중심으로, 한국국토연구원 연구보고서
  2. 김선웅(2006), 미국의 저소득층을 위한 주택정택 변화와 시사점, 국토 8월, 102-111
  3. 신경주.문학조(2007), 한국과 미국 임대아파트 평면의 특징 비교 -양천구 SH공사 아파트와 Saint Paul PHA 아파트를 중심으로-, 한국실내디자인학회지, 16(6), 86-95
  4. 신경주.장상옥(2007a). 한국과 미국 공공 임대아파트의 거주자특성과 생활지원서비스 비교, 한국생활환경학회지, 14(4), 384-401
  5. 신경주.장상옥(2007b). 살기 좋은 지역만들기 관점에서 본 생활지원서비스와 연계한 공공임대아파트의 방향 -서울 SH공사 아파트와 미국 세인트폴시 PHA 아파트의 질적 연구-, 한국주거학회논문집, 18(6), 25-34
  6. 장영희(2006), 재개발임대주택 정책개선 방안, 연구보고서, 서울시정개발연구원
  7. 최정민(2005), 영구임대아파트에 대한 불만도 및 인식 평가, 대한건축학회논문집 계획계, 21(12), 235-246
  8. Wilder Research Center (2002), Service needs and satisfaction levels of hi-rise residents-A report to the Saint Paul Public Housing Agenc
  9. http://www.stpaulpha.org, 세인트폴 PHA 홈페이지