A Proposal for Use in Research Methodology of Traditional Medicine in East Asia - Historical Evidence-Based Medicine -

전통한의학 연구방법론의 현대화에 대한 소고(小考) - 역사적 근거중심의학에 대한 제언 -

  • Eom, Seok-Ki (Kwanghyewon Medical Foundation) ;
  • Kim, Se-Hyun (Dept. of East-West Medicine, Graduate School of East-West Medicine, Kyunghee University) ;
  • Choi, Won-Cheol (Dept. of Clinical Traditional Oncology, College of Oriental Medicine, Kyunghee University)
  • 엄석기 (광혜원 한방병원) ;
  • 김세현 (경희대학교 동서의학대학원 동서의학과) ;
  • 최원철 (경희대학교 한의과대학 임상종양학교실)
  • Received : 2010.02.18
  • Accepted : 2010.03.18
  • Published : 2010.03.25

Abstract

Research methodology on Traditional Medicine in East Asia refers to logical thinking system, empirical positivism system and methodology of developing these knowledge systems. Logical thinking system of abstract concepts such as analogy or abduction and positivism system of reasonable explanation such as the five elements and their characteristic theory have been used in various ways empirically or in the form of humanities and knowledge system was developed through parallel structure of empirical positivism and exegetical studies. After the 16th century, evidence was required along with the tradition of putting emphasis on rationality, logicality and empirical positivism and characteristics of medical humanities can be found in emphasizing on medical ethics. Data that can be considered as structural review paper or meta analysis from original data of research on Traditional East Asian Medicine should be evaluated as historical evidence which is equivalent to specialist opinion, descriptive disease research, single case report or case series. Historical evidence based medicine is a research method using Historical evidence to selectively support data that are faithful to traditional theory with higher possibility to be used in future traditional east Asian medicine that links between traditional knowledge and scientific research methodology. Moreover, historical evidence based medicine tries to re-evaluate the value of traditional knowledge and ultimately, guides the direction of development of traditional medicine through scientific rationality based on history and culture.

Keywords

References

  1. 김경석. 폐암의 한방치료에 관한 근거중심의학에 기반한 임상연구방법론. 2010. 세명대학교 대학원 박사학위논문. pp.1-2, 49-50.
  2. 백유상, 정우진. 類比推理를 통해 본 韓醫學 理論構成의 과정. 2006. 대한한의학원전학회지. 19(4). pp.202-211.
  3. 엄석기. 한의학 문헌분류에 관한 연구. 원광대학교 대학원 박사학위. 2004. pp.180-181.
  4. 유병완, 정헌영, 이시형, 조은희, 금경수. 한의학연구방법론에 관한 연구-보편성과 특수성을 중심으로-. 대한한의학원전학회지. 2008. 21(4). p.134. pp.137-139.
  5. 정우열. 동양학으로서의 한의학. 전통학의 재발견(21세기 동양학의 재조명 제 2차 학술대회자료집). 대구. 영산대학교 동양문화연구원. 2000. p.7.
  6. 김치우. 古書의 傳統的 整理方法에 관한 問題와 對策. 부산. 부산여대논문집 제14집. 1983. 14(1). p.464.
  7. Guyatt GH. Evidence based medicine. ACP journal club. 1991. March/April. p.A-16.
  8. Ralph B D;Agostino, Debate: The slippery slope of surrogate outcomes. Curr Control Trials Cardiovasc Med. 2000. 1. pp.76-78. https://doi.org/10.1186/CVM-1-2-076
  9. 김수영. 근거중심의학. 2001. 연세의학교육. 3(1). 2001. p.3, 6.
  10. 맹광호. 임상증례 보고논문 작성법. 서울. 계축문화사. 2002. p.51, 52, 53, 54. pp.55-65.
  11. 성태제, 시기자 공저. 연구방법론. 서울. 학지사. 2006. pp.30-38.
  12. 이중원 외. 인문학으로 과학 읽기(실천인문총서 3). 서울. 실천문학사. 2009.
  13. 홍원식 윤창열 편저. 신편중국의학사. 대전. 주민출판사. 2004. p.301. pp.33-34.
  14. 전국한의과대학원전학교실 편. 유편황제내경(개정판). 대전. 주민출판사. 2006. pp.869-870.
  15. Edward O. Wilson 지음, 최재천 김길원 옮김. 우리는 지금도 야생을 산다. 서울. 바다출판사. 2005. p.112.
  16. 엄석기, 김세현, 최원철. A History of Research Methodology in Traditional Medical Systems of East Asia -Turning Tradition Into Modern : BC 12C∼AD 21C. The 3rd International Symposium of East-West Medicine for Cancer Therapy. 2008. 포스터 발표.
  17. 조병희. 양한방관계와 통합의학의 전망. pp. 5-6.
  18. http://snu-dhpm.ac.kr/pds/files/%BE%E7%C7%D1%B9%E6%B0%FC%B0%E8(%B0%F8%C5%EB%C1%A1).pdf. 2010.03.23.