Journal of Information Technology Services (한국IT서비스학회지)

Korea Society of IT Services (한국IT서비스학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Study on Open Appraisal System Modeling for Government Research and Development Program through Review of Law and Administrative Rules : Focused on Clean Appraisal System

국가연구개발사업에 있어서 제도적 차원의 개방형 평가 시스템 모델링에 관한 연구 : 클린평가시스템을 중심으로

  • 이동한 (가천대학교 산학협력단) ;
  • 지명근 (한양대학교 정보시스템학과) ;
  • 이욱 (한양대학교 정보시스템학과)
  • Received : 2015.04.14
  • Accepted : 2015.12.14
  • Published : 2015.12.31
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

Governments around the world invest in research and development (R&D) for different purposes : national economy, defence, environment, health, etc. as a means of national survival beyond the means of national competitiveness. These are usually programs with high social impact but low short-term economic impact or large scientific programs that are too expensive and risky for private sector investment alone. The Republic of Korea has also shown a very successful model of economic progress and social development through government R&D programs. However, there have been many corruption scandals behind it while selecting awardees for government R&D programs in Korea. So, the Republic of Korea focused on reforming appraisal system for government R&D and began preparation for "Clean Appraisal System" last year. In this study, first we analyzed the related appraisal tasks through the review of laws and administrative rules and typed appraisal tasks according to the flow of the actors and time. Thus securing the information infrastructure and finally we drew the conceptual model of the system according to an open appraisal tasks by introducing an element of the OECD on open government typed appraisal tasks.

Keywords

References

  1. Ahn, B.M., "PCT Patent Application Status of the Major Country and Korea based on WIPO data", KISTEP Statistic Brief, Vol.26, 2014, 1-17.(안병민, "WIPO 자료로 살펴본 우리나라와 주요국의 PCT 특허 출원 현황", KISTEP 통계 브리프, 제26권, 2014, 1-17.)
  2. Anti-Corruption and Civil Rights Commission, Eradication Plan on National R&D Moral Hazard, Anti-Corruption and Civil Rights Commission, Korea, 2009.(국민권익위원회, "국가 R&D 사업 도덕적 해이 근절 대책 마련", 국민권익위원회, 대한민국, 2009.)
  3. Anti-Corruption and Civil Rights Commission, "Recommendations for Improving Transparency of National R&D", Anti-Corruption and Civil Rights Commission, Korea, 2009.(국민권익위원회, "국가연구개발사업 투명성 제고를 위한 제도개선 권고안", 국민권익위원회, 대한민국, 2009.)
  4. Government of the Republic of Korea, "Presidential Decree No.26500 Regulations on the Management, etc. of National Research and Development Projects", Government of the Republic of Korea, Korea, 2015.(대한민국정부, 대통령령 제26500호 국가연구개발사업의 관리 등에 관한 규정, 대한민국정부, 대한민국, 2015.)
  5. Hwang, J.Y., "Improvement of National R&D Project Evaluation", Korea Science and Engineering Foundation, Korea, 2009.(황준영, "국가 R&D과제 평가 개선에 대한 연구", 한국과학재단, 대한민국, 2009.)
  6. Kim, I.J., "2014 Year Analysis on Government R&D Budget and Funds, Korea Institute of Science Technology Evaluation and Planning", Korea, 2014.(김인직, 2014년 정부연구개발예산.기금 현황 분석, 한국과학기술기획평가원, 대한민국, 2014.)
  7. Korea Meteorological Industry Promotion Agency, "Report of Research Management Agencies", Korea Meteorological Industry Promotion Agency, Korea, 2013.(한국기상산업진흥원, 연구관리 전문기관 현황, 한국기상산업진흥원, 대한민국, 2013.)
  8. Lee, E.A., "The Current Operation Status of an Evaluation System for R&D Project and its Improved Method", Kyungpook National University, Korea, 2009.(이은아, "연구개발사업 평가 시스템 운영실태 및 개선방안", 경북대학교 석사 학위 논문, 2009.)
  9. Lee, J.A., "Strategies for Public Information Open and Use of the Smart Government", CIO REPORT, Vol.28, 2010, 1-19.(이정아, "스마트 정부의 공공정보 개방과 이용 활성화 전략", CIO REPORT, 제28권, 2010, 1-19.)
  10. Ministry of Education and Science Technology, "Overview of National Research and Development Accomplishment", Ministry of Education and Science Technology, Korea, 2009.(교육과학기술부, 국가연구개발사업 성과 총람, 교육과학기술부, 대한민국, 2009.)
  11. Ministry of Science, "ICT and Future Planning, Rising of cited Korean SCI Papers", Ministry of Science, ICT and Future Planning, Korea, 2014(미래창조과학부, "우리나라 SCI 논문수 1편당 피인용 횟수 상승", 미래창조과학부, 대한민국, 2014.)
  12. Ministry of Schience, ICT and Future Planning, "Science and Technology Statistics", Available at http://sts.ntis.go.kr(Accessed April 3. 2015).(미래창조과학부, "과학기술통계", http://sts.ntis.go.kr, Accessed April 3. 2015.)
  13. Ministry of Science, "ICT and Future Planning, Standards Manual for Management of National Research and Development Research", Ministry of Science, ICT and Future Planning, Korea, 2014.(미래창조과학부, 국가연구개발사업 연구관리 표준매뉴얼, 미래창조과학부, 대한민국, 2014.)
  14. Ministry of Science, "ICT and Future Planning, 2014 Year National Science and Technology Knowledge and Information Services Detailed Plans", Ministry of Science, ICT and Future Planning, Korea, 2015.(미래창조과학부, "2014년 국가과학기술지식정보서비스 세부 추진 계획", 미래창조과학부, 대한민국, 2015.)
  15. Ministry of Strategy and Finance, "Function Adjustment of Employment, Welfare and SME Sector Public Institutions", Ministry of Strategy and Finance, Korea, 2015.(기획재정부, "고용.복지 분야 및 중소기업 분야 공공기관 기능 조정", 기획재정부, 대한민국, 2015.)
  16. Moon Jung Wook, "Introduction on Strategy of the US for Open Government Implementation with IT focused on Data.gov", Broadcasting and Communications Policy, Vol. 21, No.16, 2009, 100-105.(문정욱, "미국의 IT를 활용한 열린 정부 구현 전략 소개 : Data.gov를 중심으로", 정보통신정책연구원 방송통신정책, 제21권, 제16호, 2009, 100-105.)
  17. National Assembly Budget Office, "2015 Year R&D budget analysis", National Assembly Budget Office, Korea, 2014.(국회예산정책처, 2015년 R&D 예산 분석, 국회예산정책처, 대한민국, 2014.)
  18. National Information Society Agency, "2003 Year National Informatization White Paper", National Information Society Agency, Korea, 2003.(한국정보화진흥원, "2003 국가정보화백서", 한국정보화진흥원, 대한민국, 2003.)
  19. National Science and Technology Commission, "Improvement on National Research and Development Classification System", National Science and Technology Commission, Korea, 2009.(국가과학기술위원회, "국가연구개발 분류체계 개선 방안", 국가과학기술위원회, 대한민국, 2009.)
  20. National Science and Technology Commission, "National Science and Technology Information System Plan", National Science and Technology Commission, Korea, 2004.(국가과학기술위원회, "국가과학기술종합정보시스템 구축 계획, 국가과학기술위원회", 대한민국, 2004.)
  21. OECD, "Frascati manual : Proposed Standard Practice for Surveys on Research and Experimental Development", OECD, France, 2002.
  22. OECD, "Main Science and Technology Indicators", OECD, France, 2014.
  23. OECD, "Modernising Governmnet : The Way Forward", OECD, France, 2005.
  24. OECD, "The Government Challenge and Ensuring Economic Recovery", OECD, France, 2009.
  25. Prosecution Service, "Investigation Results on Government Contributions and Government Institutions Corruption Case", Prosecution Service, Korea, 2008(창원지방검찰청, 공공기관.정부출연금 비리사건 중간 수사 결과, 창원지방검찰청, 대한민국, 2008.)
  26. Rossi, P.H., M.W. Lipsey, and H.E. Freeman, Evaluation : A systematic approach 5th Edition, Sage Publication, Newsbury Park CA, 1993.
  27. Small and Medium Business Administration, "First Introduction of Transparent and Easy Clean Appraisal System", Small and Medium Business Administration, Korea, 2014.(중소기업청, "중기청 투명하고 편리한 클린평가시스템 최초 도입", 중소기업청, 대한민국, 2014.)
  28. Small and Medium Business Administration, "Management Guidelines for SME R&D", Small and Medium Business Administration, Korea, 2014.(중소기업청, 중소기업기술개발사업 관리지침, 중소기업청, 대한민국, 2014.)
  29. Um, I.C. and J.J. Lee, "Investment Analysis and Future Directions on Plan of Government Investment in Research and Development in 2010", Science and Technology, Vol.487, 2009, 40-43.(엄익천, 이장재, "2010년도 정부 연구개발투자의 편성(안) 분석과 향후 투자 방향", 과학과 기술, 제487권, 2009, 40-43.)