DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Analysis of Contents related to Models in the Chemistry Textbooks of the 2009 & 2015 Revised Curricula: Focusing on the Electrolysis of Aqueous Solutions

2009 및 2015 개정 교육과정의 화학 교과서에서 모델 관련 내용 분석: 수용액 전기 분해를 중심으로

  • Kim, Kihyang (Sejong Academy of Science and Arts) ;
  • Chang, Hasok (Department of History and Philosophy of Science, University of Cambridge) ;
  • Paik, Seoung-Hey (Department of Chemistry Education, Korea National University of Education)
  • 김기향 (세종과학예술영재학교) ;
  • 장하석 (영국 케임브리지대 과학사.과학철학과) ;
  • 백성혜 (한국교원대학교 화학교육과)
  • Received : 2019.02.18
  • Accepted : 2019.06.03
  • Published : 2019.08.20

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to compare the contents of chemistry textbooks developed according to the 2015 revised curriculum with the contents of the 2009 revised curriculum to research the change in "the development and use of models". To do this, we analyzed 8 kinds of Chemistry I textbooks and 6 kinds of Chemistry II textbooks from the 2015 revised curriculum and compared them with 4 kinds of Chemistry I textbooks and 4 kinds of Chemistry II textbooks from the 2009 revised curriculum. The scope of the analysis was the explanations of the textbooks related to aqueous electrolysis experiments. In order to compare the contents regarding electrolytes when the same experiments are interpreted with different models, we analyzed contents of 4 kinds of middle school science textbooks from the 2015 revised curriculum and 9 kinds of middle school science textbooks from the 2009 revised curriculum. As a result of the analysis, the same experiment was explained by different models according to the grade level and unit, and all explanations were limited to a single model. Also, the tendency to limit the kinds of electrolytes for controlled experimental results is more pronounced in the 2015 revised curriculum than in the 2009 revised curriculum. From this results, we suggest that efforts are needed to reflect the "development and use of models" in chemistry textbooks developed according to the 2015 revised curriculum.

이 연구에서는 2015 개정 교육과정의 교과서에서 "모델의 개발과 사용"이라는 항목에서 변화가 있는지 확인하기 위하여 2009 개정 교육과정의 교과서 내용과 비교 분석하였다. 이를 위하여 2015 개정 교육과정의 화학 I 교과서 8종, 화학 II 교과서 6종을 분석하였으며, 2009 개정 교육과정의 화학 I 교과서 4종, 화학 II 교과서 4종을 비교 분석하였다. 분석 범위는 수용액의 전기 분해에 관련된 내용만 선택하였다. 또한 동일한 실험을 다른 모델로 해석하는 전해질 관련 내용을 비교하기 위하여 2015 개정 교육과정 중학교 과학 2 교과서 4종의 관련 단원 내용을 2009 개정 교육과정의 중학교 과학 2 교과서 9종과 비교 분석하였다. 분석 결과, 학년과 단원에 따라 동일한 실험을 다른 모델로 설명하고 있었으며, 모든 설명은 단일 모델로 제한하여 제시하였다. 또한 모델과 일치하지 않을 수 있는 실험 결과가 나오는 전해질의 종류를 제한하는 경향이 2009 개정 교육과정보다 2015 개정 교육과정에서 더 뚜렷하게 나타났다. 이 결과는 2015 개정 교육과정에서 개발된 교과서에서 "모델의 개발과 사용"을 반영하기 위한 노력이 필요함을 시사한다.

Keywords

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0001.png 이미지

Figure 1. The three spheres of activity for scientists and engineers.1

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0002.png 이미지

Figure 2. Model of science activity.20

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0003.png 이미지

Figure 3. Modified model for students’ activity in classroom.24

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0004.png 이미지

Figure 4. Modified model in science textbooks.24

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0005.png 이미지

Figure 5. A graphic representation of Priestley’s metaphor concerning the growth of knowledge and ignorance.36

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0006.png 이미지

Figure 6. The model of electrolysis of water in Chemistry I textbook of the 2015 revised curriculum.53

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0007.png 이미지

Figure 7. An electrolysis experiment of chemistry I textbook of the 2015 revised curriculum.49

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0008.png 이미지

Figure 8. One modern view of the electrolysis of water.74

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0009.png 이미지

Figure 9. An experiment of electrolysis of water in Chemistry I textbook of the 2009 revised curriculum.40

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0010.png 이미지

Figure 10. The model to explain the phenomena that current flows when the ionic compounds dissolve in water in Chemistry I textbook of the 2015 revised curriculum.51

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0011.png 이미지

Figure 11. An experiment to confirm existence of charged ions in Science 2 textbook.70

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0012.png 이미지

Figure 12. The model to explain the phenomena in which electric current flows due to charged ions in Science 2 textbook of the 2015 revised curriculum.70

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0013.png 이미지

Figure 13. The model to explain the phenomena in which electric current flows due to charged ions in Science 2 textbook of the 2015 revised curriculum.63

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0014.png 이미지

Figure 14. An experiment of electrolysis of water in Science 2 textbook of the 2009 revised curriculum.62

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0015.png 이미지

Figure 15. An experiment of electrolysis of NaCl aqueous solution in Chemistry II textbook of the 2015 revised curriculum.57

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0016.png 이미지

Figure 16. Color change of indicator depending on acidity of solution after electrolysis.

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0017.png 이미지

Figure 17. Change of carbon electrode after electrolysis in KNO3 (aq) solution (left), NaOH (aq) solution (right).

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0018.png 이미지

Figure 18. Electrolysis of 1M KNO3 electrolyte solution with in SSC Apparatus.

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_f0019.png 이미지

Figure 19. Electrolysis of KNO3 electrolyte solution with different concentration in SSC apparatus (The red arrow is the (+) pole, the blue arrow is the (-) pole).

Table 1. Contents of the textbooks developed according to the 2009 revised curriculum

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_t0001.png 이미지

Table 2. Contents of the textbooks developed according to the 2015 revised curriculum

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_t0002.png 이미지

Table 3. The ratio of gas volumes generated by electrolysis according to the concentration of Na2SO4(aq)

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_t0003.png 이미지

Table 4. The ratio of gas volumes according to types and concentration of the electrolyte

JCGMDC_2019_v63n4_289_t0004.png 이미지

References

  1. NGSS Lead States. Next Generation Science Standards: For States, By States; The National Academies Press: Washington, DC: 2013; Available at http://www.nextgenscience.org/
  2. Jeong, J.-H.; Kang, N.-H. New Physics: Sae Mulli 2016, 66(6), 705. https://doi.org/10.3938/NPSM.66.705
  3. Ministry of Education. National Science Curriculum. No. 2015-74. Sejong: Ministry of Education. 2015.
  4. Kang, N.-H. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education 2017, 37(1), 143. https://doi.org/10.14697/jkase.2017.37.1.0143
  5. Gobert, J. D.; Buckley, B. C. International Journal of Science Education 2000, 22(9), 891. https://doi.org/10.1080/095006900416839
  6. Chamizo, J. A. Science and Education 2013, 22(7), 1613. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-011-9407-7
  7. Oh, P. S. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education 2007, 27(7), 645.
  8. Oh, P. S.; Oh, S. J. International Journal of Science Education 2011, 33(8), 1109. https://doi.org/10.1080/09500693.2010.502191
  9. Cha, J. H.; Kim, Y. H.; Noh, T. H. Journal of the Korean Chemical Society 2004, 48(6), 638. https://doi.org/10.5012/jkcs.2004.48.6.638
  10. Ha, J. H.; Lee, H. J.; Kang, S. J. Journal of Gifted/Talented Education 2009, 19(1), 187.
  11. Chi, M. T. H.; Feltovich, P. J.; Glaser, R. Cognitive Science 1981, 5(2), 121. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15516709cog0502_2
  12. Gilbert, J. K. Visualization: an emergent field of practice and enquiry in science education. In Visualization: Theory and Practice in Science Education; Gilbert, J. K., Reiner, M., Nakhleh, M., Eds.; Kluwer Academic: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2008.
  13. Gilbert, J. K.; Boulter, C. J.; Rutherford, M. International Journal of Science Education 1998, 20(1), 83. https://doi.org/10.1080/0950069980200106
  14. Halloun, I. A. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 1996, 33(9), 1019. https://doi.org/10.1002/(SICI)1098-2736(199611)33:9<1019::AID-TEA4>3.0.CO;2-I
  15. Hestenes, D. American Journal of Physics 1987, 55(5), 440. https://doi.org/10.1119/1.15129
  16. Treagust, D. F.; Chittelborough, G. D.; Mamiala, T. L. International Journal of Science Education 2002, 24(4), 357. https://doi.org/10.1080/09500690110066485
  17. Magnani, L.; Casadio, C. M. Model-based Reasoning in Science and Technology; Springer: NY. 2016.
  18. Ruppert, J.; Duncan, R. G.; Chinn, C. A. Research in Science Education 2019, 49(3), 921. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11165-017-9656-9
  19. Zangori, L.; Peel, A.; Kinslow, A.; Friedrichsen, P.; Sadler, T. D. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 2017, 54(10), 1249. https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.21404
  20. Giere, R. N. Understanding Scientific Reasoning, 3rd ed., Harcourt Brace Jovanovich: NY. 1991.
  21. Han, Y. H. Development of Classroom Inquiry Model to Improve Scientific Communication Ability. Ph.D. Thesis, Korea National University of Education, 2012.
  22. Millar, R.; Osborn, J. Beyond. Science Education for the Future; King college: London, 1998.
  23. Osborne, J.; Erduran, S.; Simon, S. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 2004, 41(10), 994. https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.20035
  24. Han, Y. H.; Lee, M. S.; Paik, S. H. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education 2007, 27(1), 50.
  25. Kwak, Y. S. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education 2004, 24(5), 1028.
  26. Song, J. W.; Na, J. Y. School Science Journal 2015, 9(2), 72. https://doi.org/10.15737/SSJ.9.2.201507.72
  27. Nott, M.; Smith, R. International Journal of Science Education 1995, 17(3), 399. https://doi.org/10.1080/0950069950170310
  28. Nott, M.; Wellington, J. J. School Science Review 1996, 76, 41.
  29. White, R. T. International Journal of Science Education 1996, 18(7), 761. https://doi.org/10.1080/0950069960180703
  30. Watson, J. R.; Swain, J. R. L.; McRobbie, C. International Journal of Science Education 2004, 26(1), 25. https://doi.org/10.1080/0950069032000072764
  31. Chang, H. S. Science Meets Philosophy; EBS Media: Seoul, 2014.
  32. Salis, F.; Frigg, R. Capturing the scientific imagination. In The Scientific Imagination; Godfrey-Smith, P.; Levy, A., Eds., Oxford University Press: NY, 2017.
  33. Gilbert, J. K. Visualization: an emergent field of practice and enquiry in science education. In Visualization: Theory and Practice in Science Education; Gilbert, J. K.; Reiner, M.; Nakhleh, M., Eds., Kluwer Academic: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2008.
  34. Morrison, M.; Morgan, M. S. Models as mediating instruments. In Models as Mediators; Morrison, M.; Morgan, M. S., Eds., Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, 1999.
  35. Rouse, W. B.; Morris, N. M. Psychological Bulletin 1986, 100(3), 349. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.100.3.349
  36. Chang, H. S. Is Water $H_2O$?: Evidence, Realism and Pluralism; Springer Science & Business Media: London, 2012.
  37. Mislevy, R. J.; Haertel, G.; Riconscente, M.; Rutstein, D. W.; Ziker, C. Design Patterns for Model-Based Reasoning. In Assessing Model-Based Reasoning using Evidence-Centered Design; Springer: London, 2017.
  38. Lehrer, R.; Schauble, L. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology 2000, 21(1), 39. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0193-3973(99)00049-0
  39. Kim S. K.; Park, C. Y.; Choi, H.; Paik, S. H. Journal of the Korean Chemical Society 2018, 62(3), 226. https://doi.org/10.5012/JKCS.2018.62.3.226
  40. Park, J. S.; Youn, Y.; Jung, J. O.; Cho, E. M.; Ryu, S. K. Chemistry I; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2011.
  41. Ryu, H. I.; Kim, C. S.; Lee, G. P.; Lee, J. B.; Bak, S. B.; Kang, S. G.; Kim, Y. Y.; Lee, H. G. Chemistry I; Visang Press: Seoul, 2011.
  42. Noh, T. H.; Choi, S. S.; Kang, S. J.; Lee, S. Y.; Bae, B. I.; Go, S. Y.; Ju, Y.; Choi, S. Y. Chemistry I; Chunjae Press: Seoul, 2011.
  43. Kim, H. J.; Kim, H. S.; Lee, B. K.; Lee, S. M.; Lee, Y. S.; Lee, J. H.; Lee, J. S.; Lee, H. N.; Cho, H. S. Chemistry I; Sangsang Academy Press: Seoul, 2011.
  44. Park, J. S.; Youn, Y.; Jung, J. O.; Cho, E. M.; Ryu, S. K. Chemistry II; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2012.
  45. Ryu, H. I.; Kim, C. S.; Lee, G. P.; Lee, J. B.; Bak, S. B.; Kang, S. G.; Kim, Y. Y.; Lee, H. G. Chemistry II; Visang Press: Seoul, 2012.
  46. Noh, T. H.; Choi, S. S.; Kang, S. J.; Lee, S. Y.; Bae, B. I.; Go, S. Y.; Ju, Y.; Choi, S. Y. Chemistry II; Chunjae Press: Seoul, 2012.
  47. Kim, H. J.; Kim, H. S.; Lee, B. K.; Lee, S. M.; Lee, Y. S.; Lee, J. H.; Lee, J. S.; Lee, H. N.; Cho, H. S. Chemistry II; Sangsang Academy Press: Seoul, 2012.
  48. Hwang, S. Y.; Jeon, H. Y.; Lee, S. H.; Noh, D. G. Chemistry I; Donga Publisher: Seoul, 2018.
  49. Choi, M. H.; Seo, I. H.; Han, M. J.; Jeong, D. Y.; Kim, H. K.; Choi, G. S. Chemistry I; Mirea-n: Seoul, 2018.
  50. Park, J. S.; Park, J. H.; Kang, S. H.; Ryu, S. K.; Sin, D. H.; Lee, S. Y.; Cho, S. Y.; Cho, H. S. Chemistry I; Visang Press: Seoul, 2018.
  51. Hong, H. K.; Jeon, H. G.; Lee, B. K.; Kim, M. S.; Seok, D. J.; Sin, I. J.; Kim, H. S. Chemistry I; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2018.
  52. Ha, Y. K.; Jeon, S. C.; Bae, B. I.; Noh, K. J.; Kang, S. H.; Kim, J. O. Chemistry I; Kumsung Publisher: Seoul, 2018.
  53. Jang, N. H.; Kang, S. J.; Park, J. B.; Lee, H. I.; Kim, H. C.; Bae, S. W.; Oh, C. J.; Og, J. S.; Lee, J. M.; Lee, H. N. Chemistry I; Sangsang Academy Press: Seoul, 2018.
  54. Lee, S. G.; Kim, Y. Y.; Lee, J. B.; Kim, H. J.; Kang, S. G.; Park, B. K.; Kim, S. H.; Park, H. J. Chemistry I; Jihaksa: Seoul, 2018.
  55. Roh, T. H.; Kang, S. J.; Ju, Y.; Go, S. Y.; Kim, Y. H.; Choi, S. Y.; Yang, C. H. Chemistry I; Seoul: Chunjea: Seoul, 2018.
  56. Choi, M. H.; Seo, I. H.; Han, M. J.; Jeong, D. Y.; Kim, H. K.; Choi, G. S. Chemistry II; Mirea-n: Seoul, 2019.
  57. Park, J. S.; Park, J. H.; Kang, S. H.; Ryu, S. K.; Sin, D. H.; Lee, S. Y.; Cho, S. Y.; Cho, H. S. Chemistry II; Visang Press: Seoul, 2019.
  58. Hong, H. K.; Jeon, H. G.; Lee, B. K.; Kim, M. S.; Seok, D. J. Sin, I. J.; Kim, H. S. Chemistry II; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2019.
  59. Jang, N. H.; Kang, S. J.; Park, J. B.; Lee, H. I.; Kim, H. C.; Bae, S. W.; Oh, C. J.; Og, J. S.; Lee, J. M.; Lee, H. N. Chemistry II; Sangsang Academy Press: Seoul, 2019.
  60. Lee, S. G.; Kim, Y. Y.; Lee, J. B.; Kim, H. J.; Kang, S. G.; Park, B. K.; Kim, S. H.; Park, H. J. Chemistry II; Jihaksa: Seoul, 2019.
  61. Roh, T. H.; Kang, S. J.; Ju, Y.; Go, S. Y.; Kim, Y. H.; Choi, S. Y.; Yang, C. H. Chemistry II; Chunjea: Seoul, 2019.
  62. Park, H. S.; Jeong, D. Y.; Shin, H. S.; Kim, J. H.; Hur, S. I.; Cho, S. Y.; You, S. N.; Lee, H. W.; Kim, J. Y.; Lee, S. J.; Choi, B. S.; Kang, S. C.; Oh, S. W. Science 2; Kyohaksa: Seoul, 2013.
  63. Lee, S. M.; Chae, K. P.; Nam, K. W.; Noh, T. H.; Seo, I. H.; Kang, S. J.; Kim, Y. S.; Kum, J. H.; Moon, K. W.; Lee, M. W.; Kwon, S. M.; Son, Y. W. Science 2; Kumsung Publisher: Seoul, 2013.
  64. Lee, J. S.; Kim, S. H.; Kim, H. R.; Kim, H. S.; Park, K. T.; Park, M. S.; Park, S. Y.; Park, Y. O.; Bae, M. J.; Song, S. J.; Lee, S. Y.; Lim, H.; Jung, D. H.; Hong, J. Y. Science 2; Dusan Donga: Seoul, 2013.
  65. Lee, K. S.; Kim, S. J.; Kim, T. I.; An, H. S.; Choi, M. H.; Kim, H. S.; Kim, H. K.; Cho, K. S.; Oh, H. S.; Bae, M. J.; Lee, J. W.; Ryu, H. K.; Choi, G. S. Science 2; Mirean: Seoul, 2013.
  66. Im, T. H.; No, S. H.; Paik, J. M.; Lee, B. Y.; Kang, D. H.; Jang, H. S.; Kim, J. S.; Lee, Y. C.; Whang, I. S.; Ko, H. D.; Sin, M. Y. Science 2; Visang: Seoul, 2013.
  67. Hyun, J. O.; Kim, H. S.; Yoon, H. K.; Kang, T. W.; Choi, W. S.; Han, I. O.; Park, M. Y.; Kim, K. S.; Ji, J. H.; Cho, H. S.; Kim, B. I.; Kim, M. K.; Son, Y. A.; Lee, T. Y. Science 2; Sinsago: Seoul, 2013.
  68. Lee, S. I.; Kim, Y. H.; Nam, K. S.; Hwang, S. Y.; Kim, Y. K.; Kwon, O. S.; Kim, K. T.; No, D. G.; Park, R. W.; Shin, S. J.; Paik, S. Y.; Yeo, J. Y.; Cho, B. J.; Jeon, B. H.; Kim, C. W. Science 2; Jihaksa: Seoul, 2013.
  69. Sin, Y. J.; Jin, M. S.; Han, M. J.; Lee, G. Y.; Jung, E. Y.; Kang, J. C.; Kang, S. J.; Shon, J. W.; Bae, Y. H.; Lee, B. W.; Im, H. Y.; Ha, E. S. Science 2; Chunjea: Seoul, 2013.
  70. Kim, H. R.; Kim, S. H.;, Kim, M. S.; Lee, J. S.; Hwang, S. Y,; Lee, S. H.; Noh, D. G.; Lim, H.; Bae, M. J.; Lee, T. W.; Gwon, O. S.; Park, K. T.; Song, S. J. Science 2; Donga: Seoul, 2019.
  71. Ahn, H. S,; Cho, Y. G.; Choi, M. H.; Kim, H. S.; Jang, C. H.; Kim, H. K.; Gwon, H. S.; Oh, H. S.; Cu, H. M.; Kang, H. J.; Kim, D. J.; Lee, J. W.; Ryu, H. K.; Moon, M. H.; Lee, Y. J.; Yu, M, I. Science 2; Mirea-n: Seoul, 2019.
  72. Im, T. H. ; Paik, J. M,; Nam, G. U.; Kang, T. W.; Kang, D. H,; Lee, B. Y.; Jang, H. S.; Kim, M. G.; Whang, I. S.; Lee, Y. C.; Ko, H. D.; Sin, M. Y. Science 2; Visang: Seoul, 2019.
  73. Roh, T. H.; Lee, B. W.; Kim, S. K.; Jang, S. J.; Lim, H. Y.; Yang, C. H.; Park, J. G.; Min, J. S.; Bae, Y. H., Oh, P. S.; Kim, Y. G.; Park, C. Y. Science 2; Chunjea: Seoul, 2019.
  74. Pauling, L.; Pauling, P. Chemistry; W. H. Freeman and Co.: San Francisco, 1975.
  75. Oxtoby, D.; Gillis, H.; Campion, A. Principles of Modern Chemistry, 7th ed.; Cengage Learning: NY, 2012.
  76. http://dongascience.donga.com/news.php?idx=26653.
  77. https://www.scienceall.com/.