The Effectiveness of Order Release Strategies considering Production Plan and Dispatching Rules

생산계획 및 우선순위규칙에 따른 Order Release 정책의 유효성에 관한 연구

  • Published : 1999.09.01

Abstract

Order Review/Release (ORR) System is the linkage between planning system and actual production. Reduction of the waiting time on the machines, work in process and lead time variation may be achieved by adopting ORR strategies. But researchers on the ORR do not agree on the effectiveness of ORR. Some say that the overall system flow time may be increased if ORR is adopted, but others say that ORR can reduce work in process, flow time and variation of flow time. The objective of this research is to clarify under what environments order release strategy is effective. Simulation study was conducted in a hypothetical job shop. The experimental results show that dispatching rule is much more important than ORR is in controlling the shop floor. But the results indicate that ORR can reduce mean shop flow time, average work in process and variation of shop flow time under such environments where utilization level is high and planned order is weekly released to the order pool. And the results also show that the effect of plan smoothing on the ORR is insignificant, which is inconsistent with the results of the previous researches.

Keywords

References

  1. Journal of Operations Management v.4 no.2 The effects of input control on the performance of a simple scheduling model Baker, K. R.
  2. International Journal of Production Research v.26 Theory and practice of load-oriented manufacturing control Bechte, W.
  3. International Journal of Production Research v.35 no.2 Order review and release strategies in a job shop environment : a review and a classification Bergamaschi, D.;Cigolini, R.;Perona, M.;Portioli, A.
  4. Journal of Operations Management v.3 The use of workload information to control job lateness in controlled and uncontrolled release production systems Bertrand, J. W. M.
  5. International Journal of Production Economics v.46 Integrating material coordination and capacity load smoothing in multi-product multi-phase production systems Bertrand, J. W. M.;van Ooijen, H. P. G.
  6. International Journal of Production Research v.27 Implementing a loading heuristic in a discrete release job shop Bobrowski, P. M.
  7. International Journal of Production Research v.27 Assessing the impact of reducing demand variance through improved planning on the performance of a dual resource constrained job shop Fredendall, L. D.;Melnyk, S. A.
  8. International Journal of Production Research v.27 Order review/release : research issues and perspectives Melnyk, S. A.;Ragatz, G. L.
  9. Journal of Operations Management v.10 no.4 Load smoothing by the planning and order review/release systems : a simulation experiment Melnyk, S. A.;Ragatz, G. L.;Fredendall, L.
  10. International Journal of Production Research v.32 no.5 Evaluating variance control, order review/release and dispatching : a regression analysis Melnyk, S. A.;Tan, K. C.;Denzler, D. R.
  11. International Journal of Production Research v.33 no.6 Load smoothing with feedback in a bottleneck job shop Park, P. S.;Salegna, G. J.
  12. Production Planning and Control v.7 no.1 An Enhanced loading model for the probabilistic workload control under imbalance Perona, M.;Portioli, A.
  13. Decision Sciences v.24 no.6 An evaluation of capacity sensitive order review and release procediures in a job shops Philipoom, P. R.;Malhotra, M. K.;Jensen, J. B.
  14. Decision Sciences v.19 An evaluation of order release mechanisms in a job shop environment Ragatz, G.;Mabert, V. A.