Journal of the Korean Society for Library and Information Science (한국문헌정보학회지)

Korean Society For Library And Information Science (한국문헌정보학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

An Analytic81 Study of Children's Book Review Media

어린이 도서 서평 매체에 관한 연구

  • 장지숙 (이화여자대학교 문헌정보학과)
  • Published : 2004.06.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

Book review Is a mean that provides Qualitative evaluation and at the same time it plays a role as selection tools for libraries. Therefore, this study Identified various media providing reviews on children's books, evaluated whether the reviews in the media were useful as selection tools of current books, and a desirable model for the book review media that would reform the existing problems was suggested. The efforts to make up for the above suggestions are needed, so that the current children's book review media can properly play a role as selection tools. Above all, at this point in time, it is necessary to publish review media made in the view of libraries and librarians.

본 연구는 어린이 도서에 대한 서평을 제공하는 각종 매체의 존재를 확인하고, 그러한 매체에 수록된 서평이 선정 도구로 적합한지를 평가하였으며, 이러한 과정을 통하여 보다 적절한 서평 매체로서의 역할을 증진하기 위해서 기존의 어린이 도서 서평 매체의 문제점을 분석하고 발전 방안을 제시하였다. 우리나라에서 활용할 수 있는 어린이 도서 서평 매체중 추천한 매체만을 대상으로 한 서평 분석 결과에 의하면 선정 도구로 활용할 수 있을 정도의 정보를 모두 제공하는 서평 매체는 없다고 할 수 있다. 따라서 도서관과 사서의 관점에서 어린이 도서를 평가한 서평 매체의 발행이 요구된다.

Keywords

References

  1. 제35회 문화관광부 추천도서 선정결과 발표 문화관광부
  2. 제36회 문화관광부 추천도서-교양부문 선정결과 발표 문화관광부
  3. 출판통계자료
  4. Library Quarterly v.68 no.2 Reviewing children's books:a content analysis Bishop Kay;Phyllis Van Orden https://doi.org/10.1086/602956
  5. Collection Management v.11 no.1/2 The Role of reviews and reviewing media in the selection process:an examination of the research record Blake Virgil L.P.
  6. Book Report v.12 no.4 The Art & science of book reviewing Boardman Edna M.
  7. In Reviews in Library Book Selection The Reviews and reviewers of best sellers Boaz Martha;Leroy,C.Merritt;Martha Boaz;Kennerth,S.Tisdel
  8. In Evaluating Children's Books:a critical look Children's librarians, reviews, and collection development Briley Dorothy;Betsy Hearne(ed.)
  9. Journal of Youth Services in Libraries v.2 no.spring Criticism of artwork in children's picture books:a content analysis Busbin,O.Mell;Susan Steinfirst
  10. RQ v.30 Profiling review writers in the library periodical literature Buttlar, Lois J.
  11. School Library Media Quarterly v.14 no.winter The Reviewing of controversial juvenile books:a study Crow Sherry R.
  12. Ph. D. diss A Content Analysis of Children's Picture Story Book Reviews Published in Selected Journals during the Year, 1981 Dodson Janelle S.
  13. Journal of Education for Library and Information Science v.31 no.2 Research and juvenile reviewing media Doll Carol A. https://doi.org/10.2307/40323399
  14. In Book Reviewing Reviewing children's books Elleman Barbara;Sylvia E. Kamerman(ed.)
  15. In Library Science Annual Reviewing for a young audience England Claire;Adele,M.Fasick;Bohdan,S.Wynar(ed.)
  16. ChildView:Evaluating and Reviewing Materials for Children England Claire;Adele,M.Fasick
  17. Developing Library and Information Center Collections Evans,G.Edward
  18. Introduction to Book Review Index 2002 Cumulation Ferguson;Danan(ed.)
  19. Library Journal v.123 no.4 Reading the reviews Fialkoff Francine
  20. Ed. D. An Analytical Study of the Extent and Nature of the Reviewing of Juvenile Books in Eight Journals and Newspapers with Special Regard to Their Usefulness as Selection Aids for School Libraries Galloway;Mabel Louise
  21. In Evaluating Children's Books:a Critical Look Children's librarians, reviews, and collection developement Harrington Janice;Betsy Hearne(ed.)
  22. School Library Journal v.39 Put it in writing:what you should know about challenges to school library materials Hopkins Dianne McAfee
  23. From Cover to Cover:Evaluating and Reviewing Children's Books Horning Kathleen T.
  24. Ph. D. diss. The Development of Children's Book Reviewing in Selected Journals from 1924-1984 Meacham Mary
  25. Reviews in Library Book Selection Merritt,Leroy C.;Martha Boaz;Kenneth S.Tisdel
  26. School Library Journal v.37 no.9 Speaking loudly for good books:promoting the wheat and winnowing the chaff Nilsen Alleen Pace
  27. Children & Books(9th ed.) Sutherland Zena
  28. Children's Books in Children's Hands:an Introduction to Their Literature Temple Charles;Miriam Martinez;Junko Yokota;Alice Naylor
  29. In Reviews in Library Book Selection Staff reviewing in library book selection Tisdel Kenneth;Leroy,C.Merritt;Martha Boaz;Kenneth,S.Tisdel
  30. A Sense of Story:Essays on Contemporary Writers for Children Townsend John Rowe
  31. Library Resources & Technical Services v.43 no.1 Criteria for reviewing children's books Wilson Margo;Kay Bishop https://doi.org/10.5860/lrts.43n1.3
  32. School Media Quarterly v.8 no.1 A Comparative analysis of juvenile book review media Witucke Virginia
  33. Serials Review v.8 no.spring The Performance of juvenile book review media Witucke Virginia