DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Limitations and Challenges of Game Regulatory Law and Policy in Korea

현행 게임규제정책의 한계와 과제 : 합리적인 규제를 위한 고려사항

  • Received : 2014.04.27
  • Accepted : 2014.07.20
  • Published : 2014.09.30

Abstract

The laws and policies governing Korea's game regulations are becoming more and more topics for debate as we enter the Age of Internet. The nature of the basis for Internet regulations and policies are not rooted in freedom of speech or fundamental values of democracy, but rather focused on solving real-world problems such as protection of the youth. Furthermore, the reality is that regulatory devices for keeping the social order such as regulating gambling are being applied directly to games without consideration on the characteristics of Internet gaming, raising concerns that the expansion of constitutional values and innovative empowerment inherent to the Internet are being weakened. The Geun-Hye Park Administration which succeeded Myung-Bak Lee's Administration, even went so far as to implement the so-called "Shutdown Policy", which prohibits access to Internet games during pre-defined time zones and also instigated a time zone selection rule. In order to curb the gambling nature of Internet games, government-led policies such as the mandatory personal identification and prohibition of player selection or in other words mandatory random player selection are being implemented. These institutions can inhibit freedom of speech, which is the basis of democracy, violate the right of equality through unreasonable discrimination between domestic and foreign service providers, and infringe upon the principles of administrative law, such as laws, due process in policies, and balance in among policies and governmental bodies. Going forward, if Korea's Internet game regulations and polices is to develop in a rational manner, regulatory frameworks will need to be designed to protect the nature of the Internet and its innovative values that enable the realization of constitutional values; for example, the Internet acting as the "catalytic media for freedom of expression as a fundamental human right ", which has already been acknowledged by the Korea's Constitutional Court. At the same time, transparent procedures should be put into place that will allow diverse participation of stakeholders including game service providers, game users, the youth and parents in the legislation and enforcement process of regulatory institutions; policies will also need to be transformed to enable not only regulatory laws but also self-regulation system to be established. And in this process, scientific and empirical analysis on the expected effects before introducing regulations and the results of enforcing regulations after being introduced will need to be strengthened.

Keywords

References

  1. Bae, Y., "Social meaning of online games and perspectives of public regulation", Social science collection of treatises, Vol.14, 2011, 136-147.
  2. Gamedonga News, "Game portals took a breath, web board game regulatory bill withdrawn", 2013.
  3. Heo, Y., Korean Constitutional Law, 7th edition, Seoul : ParkYoungSa, 2011, 584.
  4. Herald Economy, "Only 1% of juveniles use… 'Optional shut-down system' dismissed", 2013.
  5. Hwang, S.G., "A Study on the Constitutional Limits of the Regulations of Gambling Style Online Weboard Game", Journal of Law and Economic Regulation, Vol.4, No.2, 2011, 42-46.
  6. Jeon, K.R., Digital game, Gamer, Game culture, Communication Books, 2009, 8.
  7. Jo, H.G., "Discussion of introducing 'Cooling-off system' and future tasks of regulatory policy on games", Issue and Point, Vol.393, 2012, 3-4.
  8. Jung, H.K. and S.K. Song, "Legal Issues in the On-Line Game Regulation and its Solutions", Journal of Law and Economic Regulation, Vol.4, No.2, 2011, 8-16.
  9. Jung, J.H., J.H. Jeon, I.H. Lee, J.B. Lim, and S.G. Hwang, Research on freedom of expression in cyberspace and regulations on that, 2002, 72.
  10. Kang, I.H., "Analysis on employment effects of contents industries and direction of employment policies", Kocca focus, Vol.49, 2012, 8.
  11. Kim, J.H., "Age grading system for German juvenile protection and Liste der jugendgefahrdenden Medien", KyungHee Law Review, Vol.44 No.2, 2009, 72.
  12. Korean Society of Legislation Studies, Feasibility analysis for regulation and legislature of game overindulgence, 2011.
  13. Kwon, H.Y., "Liabilities and its Limitations of ISP for Freedom of Expression in the Internet : Focusing on the Internet Shut-down System", Journal of Media Law, Vol.10, No.2, 2011, 14-16.
  14. Lee, G.J., Y.S. Ko, M.S Choi, I.S. Choi, H.K. Kim, Direction of Improvement of legislature to prevent and address Internet addition, 2010, 7-8.
  15. Lee, J.H., "The economic constitution as a basic legal order of the State on the economy", Public Law Journal, Vol.14, No.2, 2013, 297-298.
  16. Lee, M.Y., "Administrative law consideration regarding regulation on game industries", Information and Communications Policy, Vol. 18 No.14, 2006, 41-42.
  17. Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism, Sports and Tourism, "MCST pursues measures to prevent privatization of web board games again-cut off speculative operation of web board game through revision of reinforcement ordinance of game law", 2013.
  18. Regulatory Reform Committee, result report of hosting 310th plenary committee, 2013.
  19. Seong, N.I., Constitutional Study, Gyeonggi : Bobmunsa, 2012, 559.
  20. Yonhap News, "Domestic prevalence rate of internet and game addiction is low", 2014.
  21. Yonhap News, "One month of shut-down system ... Kids sniff", 2011.
  22. Yonhap News, "Only 4.5% decrease in game access at late night by juveniles after shutdown system", 2012.